^ "article"

^ array:13 [
  "alt" => ""
  "array" => array:7 [
    0 => "https:"
    1 => "www.hesge.ch"
    2 => "head"
    3 => "issue"
    4 => "en"
    5 => "publications"
    6 => "deeply-ecological-art-marie-anne-lanavere"
  ]
  "current" => "en"
  "display_alt" => "fr"
  "item" => Drupal\node\Entity\Node {#1822
    #entityTypeId: "node"
    #enforceIsNew: &2 null
    #typedData: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896
      #definition: Drupal\Core\Entity\TypedData\EntityDataDefinition {#1904
        #definition: array:1 [
          "constraints" => array:2 [
            "EntityType" => "node"
            "Bundle" => array:1 [ …1]
          ]
        ]
        #typedDataManager: null
        #propertyDefinitions: array:45 [
          "nid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1919
            #definition: array:6 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1920 …5}
              "read-only" => true
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "nid"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807
              #discovery: null
              #factory: null
              #mapper: null
              #cacheKey: "typed_data_types_plugins"
              #cacheTags: []
              #alterHook: "data_type_info"
              #subdir: "Plugin/DataType"
              #moduleHandler: Drupal\Core\Extension\ModuleHandler {#30 …12}
              #defaults: []
              #pluginDefinitionAnnotationName: "Drupal\Core\TypedData\Annotation\DataType"
              #pluginInterface: null
              #namespaces: ArrayObject {#305 …5}
              #additionalAnnotationNamespaces: []
              #definitions: array:274 [ …274]
              #cacheBackend: Drupal\Core\Cache\DatabaseBackend {#296 …5}
              #useCaches: true
              #validator: null
              #constraintManager: Drupal\Core\Validation\ConstraintManager {#303 …17}
              #prototypes: array:127 [ …127]
              #classResolver: Drupal\Core\DependencyInjection\ClassResolver {#62 …4}
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              +"_serviceId": "typed_data_manager"
            }
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1921
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1919}
            }
            #type: "integer"
            #propertyDefinitions: array:1 [
              "value" => Drupal\Core\TypedData\DataDefinition {#6136 …2}
            ]
            #schema: array:4 [
              "columns" => array:1 [ …1]
              "unique keys" => []
              "indexes" => []
              "foreign keys" => []
            ]
            #indexes: []
          }
          "uuid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1922
            #definition: array:6 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1923 …5}
              "read-only" => true
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "uuid"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1924
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1922}
            }
            #type: "uuid"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "vid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1925
            #definition: array:6 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1926 …5}
              "read-only" => true
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "vid"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1927
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1925}
            }
            #type: "integer"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "langcode" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1928
            #definition: array:8 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1929 …5}
              "display" => array:2 [ …2]
              "revisionable" => true
              "translatable" => true
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "langcode"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1930
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1928}
            }
            #type: "language"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "type" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1931
            #definition: array:7 [
              "label" => "Type de contenu"
              "required" => true
              "read-only" => true
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "type"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1932
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1931}
            }
            #type: "entity_reference"
            #propertyDefinitions: array:2 [
              "target_id" => Drupal\Core\TypedData\DataReferenceTargetDefinition {#3403 …2}
              "entity" => Drupal\Core\TypedData\DataReferenceDefinition {#5279 …3}
            ]
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "revision_timestamp" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1933
            #definition: array:7 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1934 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1935 …5}
              "revisionable" => true
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "revision_timestamp"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1936
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1933}
            }
            #type: "created"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "revision_uid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1937
            #definition: array:7 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1938 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1939 …5}
              "revisionable" => true
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "revision_uid"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1940
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1937}
            }
            #type: "entity_reference"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "revision_log" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1941
            #definition: array:9 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1942 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1943 …5}
              "revisionable" => true
              "default_value" => array:1 [ …1]
              "display" => array:1 [ …1]
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "revision_log"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1944
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1941}
            }
            #type: "string_long"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "status" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1945
            #definition: array:9 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1946 …5}
              "revisionable" => true
              "translatable" => true
              "default_value" => array:1 [ …1]
              "display" => array:1 [ …1]
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "status"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1947
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1945}
            }
            #type: "boolean"
            #propertyDefinitions: array:1 [
              "value" => Drupal\Core\TypedData\DataDefinition {#2974 …2}
            ]
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "uid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1950
            #definition: array:10 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1951 …5}
              "translatable" => true
              "default_value_callback" => "Drupal\node\Entity\Node::getDefaultEntityOwner"
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1952 …5}
              "revisionable" => true
              "display" => array:2 [ …2]
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "uid"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1953
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1950}
            }
            #type: "entity_reference"
            #propertyDefinitions: array:2 [
              "target_id" => Drupal\Core\TypedData\DataReferenceTargetDefinition {#2693 …2}
              "entity" => Drupal\Core\TypedData\DataReferenceDefinition {#2695 …3}
            ]
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "title" => Drupal\Core\Field\Entity\BaseFieldOverride {#2014
            #entityTypeId: "base_field_override"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.title"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "621795ea-d9f7-40d6-8cdb-96be2cf95e79"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [
              "config" => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.title"
            #field_name: "title"
            #field_type: "string"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Titre admin"
            #description: ""
            #settings: []
            #required: true
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2704
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\Entity\BaseFieldOverride {#2014}
            }
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #baseFieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1954
              #definition: array:9 [ …9]
              #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
              #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1956 …3}
              #type: "string"
              #propertyDefinitions: array:1 [ …1]
              #schema: array:4 [ …4]
              #indexes: []
            }
          }
          "created" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1957
            #definition: array:9 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1958 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1959 …5}
              "revisionable" => true
              "translatable" => true
              "display" => array:2 [ …2]
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "created"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1960
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1957}
            }
            #type: "created"
            #propertyDefinitions: array:1 [
              "value" => Drupal\Core\TypedData\DataDefinition {#2712 …2}
            ]
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "changed" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1961
            #definition: array:8 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1962 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1963 …5}
              "revisionable" => true
              "translatable" => true
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "changed"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1964
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1961}
            }
            #type: "changed"
            #propertyDefinitions: array:1 [
              "value" => Drupal\Core\TypedData\DataDefinition {#3508 …2}
            ]
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "promote" => Drupal\Core\Field\Entity\BaseFieldOverride {#2015
            #entityTypeId: "base_field_override"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.promote"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "821ef834-6f9c-4364-919a-d3dbdb2d0c70"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [
              "config" => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.promote"
            #field_name: "promote"
            #field_type: "boolean"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Promu en page d'accueil"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [
              "on_label" => "Activé"
              "off_label" => "Désactivé"
            ]
            #required: false
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: array:1 [
              0 => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: null
            #itemDefinition: null
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #baseFieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1965
              #definition: array:9 [ …9]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1967 …3}
              #type: "boolean"
              #propertyDefinitions: null
              #schema: null
              #indexes: []
            }
          }
          "sticky" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1970
            #definition: array:9 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1971 …5}
              "revisionable" => true
              "translatable" => true
              "default_value" => array:1 [ …1]
              "display" => array:1 [ …1]
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "sticky"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1972
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1970}
            }
            #type: "boolean"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "default_langcode" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1975
            #definition: array:9 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1976 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1977 …5}
              "translatable" => true
              "revisionable" => true
              "default_value" => array:1 [ …1]
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "default_langcode"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1978
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1975}
            }
            #type: "boolean"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "revision_default" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1981
            #definition: array:10 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1982 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1983 …5}
              "storage_required" => true
              "internal" => true
              "translatable" => false
              "revisionable" => true
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "revision_default"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1984
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1981}
            }
            #type: "boolean"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "revision_translation_affected" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1987
            #definition: array:9 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1988 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1989 …5}
              "read-only" => true
              "revisionable" => true
              "translatable" => true
              "provider" => "node"
              "field_name" => "revision_translation_affected"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1990
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1987}
            }
            #type: "boolean"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "metatag" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1993
            #definition: array:9 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1994 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1995 …5}
              "class" => "\Drupal\metatag\Plugin\Field\MetatagEntityFieldItemList"
              "computed" => true
              "translatable" => true
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "provider" => "metatag"
              "field_name" => "metatag"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1996
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1993}
            }
            #type: "map"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "path" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1997
            #definition: array:8 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#1998 …5}
              "translatable" => true
              "display" => array:1 [ …1]
              "computed" => true
              "provider" => "path"
              "field_name" => "path"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1999
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1997}
            }
            #type: "path"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "menu_link" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2000
            #definition: array:12 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#2001 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#2002 …5}
              "revisionable" => true
              "class" => "\Drupal\token\MenuLinkFieldItemList"
              "translatable" => true
              "internal" => true
              "display" => array:2 [ …2]
              "computed" => true
              "provider" => "token"
              "field_name" => "menu_link"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2003
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2000}
            }
            #type: "entity_reference"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "content_translation_source" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2004
            #definition: array:10 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#2005 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#2006 …5}
              "default_value" => array:1 [ …1]
              "initial_value" => array:1 [ …1]
              "revisionable" => true
              "translatable" => true
              "provider" => "content_translation"
              "field_name" => "content_translation_source"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2007
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2004}
            }
            #type: "language"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "content_translation_outdated" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2008
            #definition: array:10 [
              "label" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#2009 …5}
              "description" => Drupal\Core\StringTranslation\TranslatableMarkup {#2010 …5}
              "default_value" => array:1 [ …1]
              "initial_value" => array:1 [ …1]
              "revisionable" => true
              "translatable" => true
              "provider" => "content_translation"
              "field_name" => "content_translation_outdated"
              "entity_type" => "node"
              "bundle" => null
            ]
            #typedDataManager: null
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2011
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2008}
            }
            #type: "boolean"
            #propertyDefinitions: null
            #schema: null
            #indexes: []
          }
          "field_authors" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2016
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_authors"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "0f0df090-6da2-45b5-b58b-5d6629eceb96"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [
              "config" => array:3 [ …3]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_authors"
            #field_name: "field_authors"
            #field_type: "entity_reference"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Auteur·ices"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [
              "handler" => "default:node"
              "handler_settings" => array:4 [ …4]
            ]
            #required: false
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2278
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_authors"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "6770c08e-d51b-4945-8e6b-88ba90b0719a"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_authors"
              #field_name: "field_authors"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "entity_reference"
              #module: "core"
              #settings: array:1 [ …1]
              #cardinality: -1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: array:2 [ …2]
            }
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#1906
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2016}
            }
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_citation" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2017
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_citation"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "bb851bca-4120-4374-bd33-86b82a1447f1"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: array:1 [
              "allowed_formats" => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [
              "config" => array:2 [ …2]
              "module" => array:2 [ …2]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_citation"
            #field_name: "field_citation"
            #field_type: "text_long"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Citation"
            #description: """
              Ce champ se génère tout seul avec le modèle suivant : \r\n
              Prénom Nom, « Titre – Sous-titre  », Issue, 5 mars 2025.\r\n
              \r\n
              Saisir manuellement dans ce champ pour forcer une autre formulation.
              """
            #settings: []
            #required: false
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: null
            #itemDefinition: null
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_cover_image" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2018
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_cover_image"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "c8c3b9d3-cc49-4d71-8028-25682fbda136"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [
              "config" => array:3 [ …3]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_cover_image"
            #field_name: "field_cover_image"
            #field_type: "entity_reference"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Image de couverture"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [
              "handler" => "default:media"
              "handler_settings" => array:4 [ …4]
            ]
            #required: true
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2281
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_cover_image"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "21e3434f-ecb0-4949-a472-957d3731a178"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_cover_image"
              #field_name: "field_cover_image"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "entity_reference"
              #module: "core"
              #settings: array:1 [ …1]
              #cardinality: 1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: array:4 [ …4]
              #propertyDefinitions: array:2 [ …2]
            }
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2326
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2018}
            }
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_date" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2019
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_date"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "1cc67310-76aa-4abc-bf03-1dabbcef3c37"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [
              "config" => array:2 [ …2]
              "module" => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_date"
            #field_name: "field_date"
            #field_type: "datetime"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Date"
            #description: ""
            #settings: []
            #required: true
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2282
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_date"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "feffd0bb-a3a0-4a89-a7e6-193ecd35a1b3"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_date"
              #field_name: "field_date"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "datetime"
              #module: "datetime"
              #settings: array:1 [ …1]
              #cardinality: 1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: array:2 [ …2]
            }
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2424
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2019}
            }
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_departments" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2020
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_departments"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "0ad2de40-5d4e-45de-a671-a2de66618168"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [
              "config" => array:3 [ …3]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_departments"
            #field_name: "field_departments"
            #field_type: "entity_reference"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Départements associés"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [
              "handler" => "default:taxonomy_term"
              "handler_settings" => array:4 [ …4]
            ]
            #required: false
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2283
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_departments"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "21544032-b467-412b-88d7-d810cbfee28b"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_departments"
              #field_name: "field_departments"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "entity_reference"
              #module: "core"
              #settings: array:1 [ …1]
              #cardinality: -1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: array:2 [ …2]
            }
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2437
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2020}
            }
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_license" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2021
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_license"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "55b36c94-dc83-405a-88e9-9158e4cca1cc"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [
              "config" => array:3 [ …3]
              "content" => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_license"
            #field_name: "field_license"
            #field_type: "entity_reference"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Licence"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [
              "handler" => "default:taxonomy_term"
              "handler_settings" => array:4 [ …4]
            ]
            #required: true
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: array:1 [
              0 => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2291
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_license"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "5ffabd1b-45cd-4eb4-b6d0-e9e3103b035b"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_license"
              #field_name: "field_license"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "entity_reference"
              #module: "core"
              #settings: array:1 [ …1]
              #cardinality: 1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: array:2 [ …2]
            }
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2547
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2021}
            }
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_og_description" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2022
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_og_description"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "d5b6c064-b28d-43b2-b6fa-cce6bc284fcc"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [
              "config" => array:2 [ …2]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_og_description"
            #field_name: "field_og_description"
            #field_type: "string"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Référencement : description"
            #description: "Très courte description pour le référencement (70 caractères)"
            #settings: []
            #required: false
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2292
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_og_description"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "fb75c06d-930a-4aee-af29-952c4694109f"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_og_description"
              #field_name: "field_og_description"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "string"
              #module: "core"
              #settings: array:3 [ …3]
              #cardinality: 1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: null
            }
            #itemDefinition: null
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_abstract" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2023
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_abstract"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "f7d240e6-3cc3-473b-bc74-0dd31cc2c291"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: array:1 [
              "allowed_formats" => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [
              "config" => array:2 [ …2]
              "module" => array:2 [ …2]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_abstract"
            #field_name: "field_post_abstract"
            #field_type: "text_long"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Résumé"
            #description: "Calibrage optimal : 500 signes"
            #settings: []
            #required: true
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2300
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_post_abstract"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "678691f5-501b-44f7-89c7-ad002c851cfb"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_post_abstract"
              #field_name: "field_post_abstract"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "text_long"
              #module: "text"
              #settings: []
              #cardinality: 1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: array:3 [ …3]
            }
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2564
              #definition: array:2 [ …2]
              #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
              #fieldDefinition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2023}
            }
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_embed_credit" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2024
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_embed_credit"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "c110555d-55f9-4a80-b9ba-6e03af510305"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: array:1 [
              "allowed_formats" => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [
              "config" => array:2 [ …2]
              "module" => array:2 [ …2]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_embed_credit"
            #field_name: "field_post_embed_credit"
            #field_type: "text_long"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Crédit du module"
            #description: "Exemple :  “Auteur, Titre du projet, année. Développement : Auteur”"
            #settings: []
            #required: false
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2301
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_post_embed_credit"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "c4a33dc2-020f-4a5a-9a40-4a4ee586082c"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_post_embed_credit"
              #field_name: "field_post_embed_credit"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "text_long"
              #module: "text"
              #settings: []
              #cardinality: 1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: null
            }
            #itemDefinition: null
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_embed_url" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2025
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_embed_url"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "5e127856-f5e4-45bd-af2d-a1e722c289cc"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [
              "config" => array:2 [ …2]
              "module" => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_embed_url"
            #field_name: "field_post_embed_url"
            #field_type: "link"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "URL du module"
            #description: "URL pointant vers le module interactif développé en dehors du site Issue"
            #settings: array:2 [
              "title" => 0
              "link_type" => 16
            ]
            #required: true
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: null
            #itemDefinition: null
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_images_credit" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2026
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_images_credit"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "71f4f154-a4cd-4c01-bd67-e03631c25f98"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: array:1 [
              "allowed_formats" => array:1 [ …1]
            ]
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [
              "config" => array:2 [ …2]
              "module" => array:2 [ …2]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_images_credit"
            #field_name: "field_post_images_credit"
            #field_type: "text_long"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Crédit images"
            #description: ""
            #settings: []
            #required: false
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2303
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_post_images_credit"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "0d65f7df-0429-470e-8f59-308fb964abf0"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_post_images_credit"
              #field_name: "field_post_images_credit"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "text_long"
              #module: "text"
              #settings: []
              #cardinality: 1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: null
            }
            #itemDefinition: null
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_media_images" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2027
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_media_images"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "3fddbbab-187b-4b3c-bc3f-4338da09bd1a"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [
              "config" => array:3 [ …3]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_media_images"
            #field_name: "field_post_media_images"
            #field_type: "entity_reference"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Images"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [
              "handler" => "default:media"
              "handler_settings" => array:4 [ …4]
            ]
            #required: false
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2304
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_post_media_images"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "854d1cbb-abc0-4ac7-bbb1-c6b1dbdfbb27"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_post_media_images"
              #field_name: "field_post_media_images"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "entity_reference"
              #module: "core"
              #settings: array:1 [ …1]
              #cardinality: -1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: null
            }
            #itemDefinition: null
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_media_sound" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2028
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_media_sound"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "11227f92-bd50-42da-8e0f-df569ce91e15"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [
              "config" => array:3 [ …3]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_media_sound"
            #field_name: "field_post_media_sound"
            #field_type: "entity_reference"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Podcast"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [
              "handler" => "default:media"
              "handler_settings" => array:4 [ …4]
            ]
            #required: false
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2305
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_post_media_sound"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "99634e21-aeba-4804-82ae-7e6c5ad7700d"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_post_media_sound"
              #field_name: "field_post_media_sound"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "entity_reference"
              #module: "core"
              #settings: array:1 [ …1]
              #cardinality: 1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: null
            }
            #itemDefinition: null
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_media_video" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2029
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_media_video"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "417067d1-39ec-4297-a6c4-a2a6d19ca3c2"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [
              "config" => array:3 [ …3]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_media_video"
            #field_name: "field_post_media_video"
            #field_type: "entity_reference"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Vidéo"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [
              "handler" => "default:media"
              "handler_settings" => array:4 [ …4]
            ]
            #required: false
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2306
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #originalId: "node.field_post_media_video"
              #status: true
              #uuid: "9a07f9de-e52c-488c-8256-a70e9d2cce95"
              -isUninstalling: false
              #langcode: "fr"
              #third_party_settings: []
              #_core: []
              #trustedData: false
              #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
              #isSyncing: false
              #id: "node.field_post_media_video"
              #field_name: "field_post_media_video"
              #entity_type: "node"
              #type: "entity_reference"
              #module: "core"
              #settings: array:1 [ …1]
              #cardinality: 1
              #translatable: true
              #locked: false
              #persist_with_no_fields: false
              +custom_storage: false
              #indexes: []
              #deleted: false
              #schema: null
              #propertyDefinitions: null
            }
            #itemDefinition: null
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_nature" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2030
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [
              0 => "languages:language_interface"
            ]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_nature"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "ba07adc8-04e2-40cf-aa00-34016251e5eb"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [
              "config" => array:3 [ …3]
            ]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_nature"
            #field_name: "field_post_nature"
            #field_type: "entity_reference"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Nature du contenu"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [
              "handler" => "default:taxonomy_term"
              "handler_settings" => array:4 [ …4]
            ]
            #required: true
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2307
              #entityTypeId: "field_storage_config"
              #enforceIsNew: null
              #typedData: null
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
               …29
            }
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2591 …3}
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_text" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2031
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_text"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "e79cb826-6c12-4a51-ac29-f3bab6923582"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: array:1 [ …1]
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [ …2]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_text"
            #field_name: "field_post_text"
            #field_type: "text_long"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Texte"
            #description: ""
            #settings: []
            #required: false
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2308 …33}
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2604 …3}
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_trans_credit" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2032
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_trans_credit"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "d96762fb-f058-44cf-8868-e1637260de49"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_trans_credit"
            #field_name: "field_post_trans_credit"
            #field_type: "string"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Traduction"
            #description: "Crédit de la traduction, langue source entre parenthèses."
            #settings: []
            #required: false
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2309 …33}
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2619 …3}
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_post_type" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2033
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_post_type"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "b80c0f53-8d48-4166-a054-d5f6a6e52de2"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_post_type"
            #field_name: "field_post_type"
            #field_type: "entity_reference"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Type"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [ …2]
            #required: true
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2310 …33}
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2626 …3}
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_related_publications" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2034
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_related_publications"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "709a40eb-15a8-41cd-a9a9-2f9b7f3f4c30"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [ …2]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_related_publications"
            #field_name: "field_related_publications"
            #field_type: "entity_reference_revisions"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Publications apparentées"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [ …2]
            #required: false
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: null
            #itemDefinition: null
            #constraints: array:1 [ …1]
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_subtitle" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2035
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_subtitle"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "43b6dc52-63b1-4b25-b522-09074ab430ed"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: array:1 [ …1]
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [ …2]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_subtitle"
            #field_name: "field_subtitle"
            #field_type: "text_long"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Sous-titre"
            #description: ""
            #settings: []
            #required: false
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2315 …33}
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2641 …3}
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_tags" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2036
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_tags"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "cce2579e-ea24-4147-a8f7-2f7ebeaa2356"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: []
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:1 [ …1]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_tags"
            #field_name: "field_tags"
            #field_type: "entity_reference"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Tags thématiques"
            #description: ""
            #settings: array:2 [ …2]
            #required: false
            #translatable: false
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2316 …33}
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2656 …3}
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
          "field_title_displayed" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2037
            #entityTypeId: "field_config"
            #enforceIsNew: null
            #typedData: null
            #cacheContexts: array:1 [ …1]
            #cacheTags: []
            #cacheMaxAge: -1
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #originalId: "node.post.field_title_displayed"
            #status: true
            #uuid: "c45eb7ef-4dec-4f4f-a4f0-9d3f4a42ec5d"
            -isUninstalling: false
            #langcode: "fr"
            #third_party_settings: array:1 [ …1]
            #_core: []
            #trustedData: false
            #dependencies: array:2 [ …2]
            #isSyncing: false
            #id: "node.post.field_title_displayed"
            #field_name: "field_title_displayed"
            #field_type: "text_long"
            #entity_type: "node"
            #bundle: "post"
            #label: "Titre affiché"
            #description: ""
            #settings: []
            #required: true
            #translatable: true
            #default_value: []
            #default_value_callback: ""
            #fieldStorage: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldStorageConfig {#2318 …33}
            #itemDefinition: Drupal\Core\Field\TypedData\FieldItemDataDefinition {#2677 …3}
            #constraints: []
            #propertyConstraints: []
            #deleted: false
          }
        ]
      }
      #name: null
      #parent: null
      #_serviceIds: []
      #_entityStorages: []
      #stringTranslation: null
      #typedDataManager: null
      #entity: Drupal\node\Entity\Node {#1822}
    }
    #cacheContexts: []
    #cacheTags: []
    #cacheMaxAge: -1
    #_serviceIds: []
    #_entityStorages: []
    #values: &50 array:34 [
      "nid" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => "1764"
      ]
      "vid" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => "3393"
      ]
      "type" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => "post"
      ]
      "uuid" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => "81facfed-5875-4e70-834e-52b0ceb782e3"
      ]
      "langcode" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "fr"
        "en" => "en"
      ]
      "revision_uid" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => "4"
      ]
      "revision_timestamp" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => "1744268470"
      ]
      "revision_log" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => null
      ]
      "revision_default" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => "1"
      ]
      "isDefaultRevision" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => "1"
      ]
      "status" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "1"
        "en" => "1"
      ]
      "uid" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "1"
        "en" => "1"
      ]
      "title" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "Pour un art profondément écologique"
        "en" => "For a Deeply Ecological Art"
      ]
      "created" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "1700485856"
        "en" => "1700485883"
      ]
      "changed" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "1744268470"
        "en" => "1744268470"
      ]
      "promote" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "0"
        "en" => "0"
      ]
      "sticky" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "0"
        "en" => "0"
      ]
      "default_langcode" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "1"
        "en" => "0"
      ]
      "revision_translation_affected" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "1"
        "en" => "1"
      ]
      "content_translation_source" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "und"
        "en" => "fr"
      ]
      "content_translation_outdated" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => "0"
        "en" => "0"
      ]
      "field_authors" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => array:1 [
          0 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "1429"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_cover_image" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => array:1 [
          0 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "1037"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_date" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => array:1 [
          0 => array:1 [
            "value" => "2023-11-20"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_departments" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => array:1 [
          0 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "67"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_license" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => array:1 [
          0 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "14"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_post_abstract" => array:2 [
        "en" => array:1 [
          0 => array:2 [
            "value" => "<p>In the contemporary art world, a professional sector based on the globalised market economy where I worked for over twenty years as a production manager, a curator, and later as a – mostly public – institution director, environmental awareness only started guiding my choices late in my career. I usually prioritised the production, circulation and transmission of artistic projects, and the ecological paradigm only very occasionally interfered with creative and curatorial freedom.</p>\r\n"
            "format" => "rich_text_1"
          ]
        ]
        "x-default" => array:1 [
          0 => array:2 [
            "value" => "<p>Dans l’art contemporain, un secteur professionnel basé sur l’économie de marché globalisée, et où j’ai travaillé pendant plus de vingt ans comme chargée de production, commissaire d’exposition, puis directrice, principalement en institutions publiques, la conscience écologique n’a guidé mes choix que très tardivement. La priorité était généralement donnée à la production du projet de l’artiste, à sa diffusion et à sa transmission, sans que le paradigme écologique n’interfère, ou si peu, dans la liberté de créer et de programmer.</p>\r\n"
            "format" => "rich_text_1"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_post_nature" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => array:1 [
          0 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "6"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_post_text" => array:2 [
        "en" => array:1 [
          0 => array:2 [
            "value" => """
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">In the contemporary art world, a professional sector based on the globalised market economy where I worked for over twenty years as a production manager, a curator, and later as a – mostly public – institution director, environmental awareness only started guiding my choices late in my career. I usually prioritised the production, circulation and transmission of artistic projects, and the ecological paradigm only very occasionally interfered with creative and curatorial freedom. In the aughts, institutions and private companies alike had to adapt to CSR[note]<span lang="EN-GB">(Editor’s note). Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is the management of a company’s economic, social and environmental impacts.</span>[/note] and various ISO charters and standards, out of a spirit of competitiveness, to clear their conscience, or simply out of conformism. Rather than risking the collapse of the whole system, cultural institutions quickly understood how to circumvent environmental consciousness, which if adhered to would necessarily have turned these structures on their heads. One such loophole consisted in outsourcing the issue to consulting and environmental coaching agencies. Broadly speaking, the foundations, biennales and institutions which I considered to be the most advanced and in step with current social issues had in fact succeeded – by sleight of hand – in addressing environmental matters as though they were external study subjects rather than an internal mechanism they could examine. Although based on worthy intentions, the organisation of research seminars, residencies and exhibitions not <em>with</em> but <em>on the subject of </em>ecology means these institutions can still avoid embracing a truly ecological approach of art. Perversely, without even realising it, they participate in a system that does not acknowledge the urgent necessity of change, bringing the Earth’s overshoot day earlier every year.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Shortcuts enabling action do exist, but these hopes demand that we renounce some of our advantages. An ecological approach necessarily implies that we abandon part of what has been elaborated over the past years; that we relinquish everything that we have capitalised on, in fact: valued social positions, networks, privileges and so on. This is a terribly difficult process to initiate within our professional field, where so much energy is invested in supporting creative projects and assuming a trade union-like role in negotiating statutory rights for the still overwhelmingly precarious artists and art institution workers. However, after years spent campaigning in this way, it finally became apparent to me that art – in what is, to me, its most essential features: poietics, presence and encounter – is in continual decline in our liberalist society. Moreover, though it is increasingly looked down on, art has been unable to eschew the capitalist paradigm that only values production, commodification, and media potential.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <blockquote>However, hope does sporadically blossom in art spaces, through deeply ecological work methods, uniquely embodied by people who resist their financers, their hierarchy and even their colleagues, and who know how to say “no” to artists themselves, however talented, when their creative liberty starts rhyming with economic liberalism.</blockquote>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Integrating artistic labour into a deeply ecological approach that isn’t limited to the use of certified products – such as “PEFC” paper[note](Editor’s note). The Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC) is an international forest certification organisation whose aim is to guarantee the sustainable management of forests, through a certification label for forest owners, timber contractors and companies in the forest, wood, and paper sectors.[/note] for example – implies acknowledging the loss of meaning induced by artistic production itself, particularly with regard to the resources it uses. Where do the materials I work with come from? How do I process them? What will become of them once they are processed? Making responsible choices has become almost impossible in metropolises – centres for trade and commerce where commodities transit from everywhere and nowhere, just as long as you pay. Although cities are <em>deterrestrialised</em> and city life increasingly feels like survival, this is also where hubs of activity, including cultural activity, are still being developed, and where most professional artists live, whether because of spiralling precarity or a lack of alternatives. Over a century ago, William Morris stated that our understanding of materials had been lost, not so much because of industrialisation itself as because of the division of labour necessary to increase productivity: “Even if a tree is cut down or blown down, a worse one, if any, is planted in its stead. […] the very food on which both the greater and the lesser art subsists is being destroyed; the well of art is poisoned at its spring.”[note]<span style="font-weight: 400;">William Morris, “Art Under Plutocracy”, Conference at the </span><span style="font-weight: 400;">Russell Club at University College Hall, Oxford, 1883. Reprinted in May Morris (ed.),<em>Collected Works of William Morris (1910-1915), Volume 23</em>, London: Longmans, Green &amp; Co, 1910-15. Available at<a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/morris/works/1883/pluto.htm">https://www.marxists.org/archive/morris/works/1883/pluto.htm</a> (last accessed 3 November 2023).</span>[/note]</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Writing from a political territory dealing with the crisis of the sensuous, the contemporary American anthropologist David Abram can help us reframe our relationship to materials not as exploitable resources but as presence:</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;"><mark class="question">“Of course, our human-made artifacts inevitably retain an element of more-than-human otherness. This unknowability, this otherness, resides most often in the materials from which the object is made. […] Genuine art, we might say, is simply human creation that does not stifle the nonhuman element but, rather, allows whatever is Other in the materials to continue to live and breathe.”[note]David Abram, <em>The Spell of the Sensuous. Perception and Language in a More-Than-Human World</em>, New York: Vintage Books, 1996, p. 64.[/note]</mark></p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Because the production and promotion of contemporary art, in this context, are alienating (rather than supporting an encounter with art as otherness), finding a way to connect with materials as presence would not only allow us to better inhabit the Earth but to be inhabited by it in return.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">In addition to fostering awareness on the use of materials, deep ecology could also influence the ways in which teams working in cultural institutions collaborate with the artists invited for exhibitions and residencies. Some professional contemporary artists (who suffer from exploitation themselves) unwittingly act in an extractivist manner. In this respect, I have often felt uncomfortable when artists draw inspiration from artisanal knowledge, such as the herbalist’s medicinal plants and Western indigenous wisdom (water diviners, druids, and contemporary healers), when they “steal” this knowledge without giving anything in return, when they syphon inspiration and techniques, or simply when they act too hastily, approaching the understanding of a given territory in a consumerist way. These mechanisms are painful to articulate, especially when one wants to support and respect artists and their work. But I have shared these concerns over the course of the nine years I spent at the head of the Centre International d’Art et du Paysage (CIAP) on Vassivière Island, first and foremost with my team. Together, we discussed our limits and paradoxes. These reflections were developed over time, through cooperation with artists open to debating, particularly Tiphaine Calmettes, Etienne de France, François Génot, Suzanne Husky, L’amicale mille feux, RADO, Liliana Rojas Sanchez, Natsuko Uchino, as well as researchers Cristina Consuegra and Alexis Zimmer, L’école de la terre and my fellow art centre directors Béatrice Josse and Émilie Renard.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">In order to guide visiting artists to a subtler understanding of the area, the team members at Vassivière first had to learn how to inhabit their own region. Transmitting a local way of life in order to change the working habits of artists is key in striving towards an ecology of art, not only by drawing inspiration from the histories and cultures of local communities but also by respecting them, to the degree that it is sometimes preferable to keep indigenous and vernacular lore secret, if accessing it implies a long process that requires an extended residency, or that artists come back several times in order to carry out their research.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <blockquote>To live and work ecologically in a specific place means reaffirming a local level that for a long time has been neglected by contemporary art, while also overcoming a very common neo-colonial attitude in our professional practices, by deconstructing the complex power mechanisms that involve the large institutions and small associations that exist in every region.</blockquote>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>More specifically, in a rural area like Vassivière, an ecological approach demands that we be more attuned to the territory’s subtle realities, so as not to dominate traditional or less visible forms of knowledge, and to avoid imposing the prism of urban, globalised, contemporary art. One way of working ecologically for me has been to try to slow new CIAP commissions for artworks in public space, after 30 years of accumulating sculptures in the museum’s garden. Even before I applied for the position of director, these permanent outdoor artworks felt like a form of pollution serving the tourist attractiveness of an <em>ungrounded</em> island, whose future was never decided through local cooperation. From 2014 on, my extensive conversations on the subject with Benoît Antille of the Valais School of Art (École de Design et Haute École d’Art du Valais, ÉDHÉA), based on his critique of the project economy in sculpture parks and commissioned art in nature, have helped me to question the functioning of artistic institutions in rural areas.[note]<span lang="EN-GB">Benoît Antille is currently conducting a doctoral research at the University of Amsterdam, <i>The Artist as Expert: A Critical Analysis of the Project Economy</i>.</span>[/note] We expanded these conversations together during a 2017 symposium at the CIAP, <em>L’art dans l’espace rural </em>(Art in Rural Spaces), and by attending a 2019 seminar at the Whitechapel Gallery (London) entitled <em>The Rural Assembly</em>[note]<em>The Rural Assembly: Contemporary Art and Spaces of Connection</em> [seminar], London: Whitechapel Gallery, 20-22 June 2019.[/note]<em>,</em> which helped me solve some of my intellectual predicaments in relation to the right stance to adopt when dealing with these issues.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Considering all the paradoxes and repositioning attempts I have experienced over the past few years, while working in a geographical context defined by the exploitation of resources (such as hydroelectric reservoirs and industrial forests on the Plateau de Millevaches) and public policies for the classification/protection/reservation of “nature”, I have come to realise that it is not necessarily in the places where we believe it is possible to act ecologically that we fully can. In an art centre like Vassivière, when preparing an exhibition for example, it seemed more sustainable to spend time exchanging with the local community, to listen to its aspirations for the space, to communise means in order to implement a form of wealth redistribution, and to allow artists and the team to conduct in-depth research – even if this meant organising fewer exhibitions every year, or travelling less, or occasionally deciding not to be irreproachable when it came to the biodegradability of the materials we used.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Ultimately, addressing contemporary environmental emergencies through/from art signifies relearning how to live by mastering the new skillset of the <em>business of living</em> (and of dying). Adopting a holistic approach shows us that places, nature, ourselves and others are all connected. This requires listening, increasing attentiveness and collaboration, and especially developing our sensorial perception of a more-than-human world, to quote David Abrams, in contrast with what is theoretically prevalent today. To take care of the earth and its lifeforms in everything we do, even when we’re in the city, pertains to a cosmogonic relationship that has largely been lost in Western cultures, and that we can now reinvest, including by drawing inspiration from faraway indigenous and native cultures. The Rencontres de la Ferme de Lachaud (on the Plateau de Millevaches), which I take part in every year since I moved to the Limousin area, have helped me discover and draw inspiration from anthropologists and philosophers of nature, although until recently I was unable to transpose these ideas to my life in any concrete way. The translation into French of the founding texts of ecofeminism, most notably by Cambourakis press, have helped me reconnect with Western forms of paganism, and to discover living ritual and plastic forms in the here and now, rather than having to search for them elsewhere. I organised numerous conferences at the CIAP de Vassivière and elsewhere in this spirit.[note]See for instance the seminar “Habité·e / Être habité·e&nbsp;: quelles relations au vivant&nbsp;?” organised in Eymoutiers and Cieux (Limousin) in May 2019 by Nicole Pigner, l’École de la terre, and the Cercle Gramsci of Limoges. Also see Barbara Glowczewski and Geneviève Pruvost’s visit of the CIAP with their students of the École des hautes études en sciences sociales (EHESS) to meet local healers, which resulted in the collective publication <em>Des énergies qui soignent en Montagne limousine&nbsp;: Enquête collective </em>(Geneviève Pruvost and Barbara Glowczewski, Lamazière-Basse: Maïade éditions, 2021).[/note]</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">The change in paradigm that the Western world so urgently needs in order to escape its current crisis demands that, in addition to political struggle, individuals be able to transform themselves in every sense: in their relationship to the senses, to others, to sexuality, to love, to nature, and so on. Taking this risk may entail a painful endangerment, which can only be achieved by renouncing certain privileges, in order to better nurture the attachments we really care about.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;"><mark class="question">“So, it is no longer a matter of a system of production picking up again or being curbed, but one of getting away from production as the overriding principle of our relationship to the world. …. Hence the primary importance for using this time of imposed isolation in order to describe, initially one by one, then as a group, what we are attached to; what we are ready to give up; the chains we are ready to reconstruct and those that, in our behaviour, we have decided to interrupt.”[note]Bruno Latour, “<em>What protective measures can you think of so we don’t go back to the pre-crisis production model?”</em> <a href="http://www.bruno-latour.fr/sites/default/files/downloads/P-202-AOC-ENGLISH_0.pdf">http://www.bruno-latour.fr/sites/default/files/downloads/P-202-AOC-ENGLISH_0.pdf</a>; “Imaginer les gestes-barrières contre le retour à la production d’avant-crise”, <em>AOC,</em> 29 March 2020, <a href="http://www.bruno-latour.fr/fr/node/849">http://www.bruno-latour.fr/fr/node/849</a> (last accessed 8 February 2023).[/note]</mark></p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">This was philosopher Bruno Latour’s advice during the first Covid-19 lockdown in France, which he expounded in an article and later in participative workshops entitled <em>Où Atterrir </em>(<em>Where should we land?</em>) created with S-composition[note]S-composition is a theatre company founded in 2004 by composer and producer Jean-Pierre Seyvos: <a href="https://s-composition.eu/">https://s-composition.eu/</a> (last accessed 10 March 2023).[/note] at La Mégisserie in Saint-Junien, near Limoges and elsewhere.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Although this appeal, which acted as a wake-up call in cultural milieus, has undeniably helped me to implement change on a personal level, I also needed it to take the form of narratives that spoke directly to my emotions. Nastassja Martin’s deeply moving story, published in 2019, seems like a perfect example, because of the revolutionary adequacy between her poetic style of writing, her object of study – the Evene people of Siberia – and her own transformation, not only as a researcher but as an individual in her relationship to reality.[note]<span style="font-weight: 400;">Nastassja Martin, <em>In the Eye of the Wild</em> [2019], translated by Sophie R. Lewis, New York: New York Review Books, 2021.</span>[/note] Closer to home, artist Boris Nordmann, in collaboration with the association Quartier Rouge based in Felletin (Creuse department), has been organising workshops since 2017, during which work around the human body echoes the observation of animal behaviour and writing experiments, where subjective experience meets anthropological considerations. In his “corporeal fiction”, <em>Lou Pastoral</em>, Nordmann puts himself at risk when connecting with his research subject, an endangerment that is similar to Nastassja Martin’s stance. He simultaneously succeeds in embodying corporeal forms and showing the necessity of reversing our point of view.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">When Latour’s aforementioned text, “What protective measures can you think of so we don’t go back to the pre-crisis production model?” was published, I was still in office at the CIAP de Vassivières, and rather than cultivating my interest in art’s ability to change the world, I had started realising that in order to actually change things, I needed to start by changing my own life, scale down my material needs, and be more mindful of the needs of my close relations and other <em>more-than-human</em> beings. Before Covid happened, my team had already asked that we put on fewer exhibitions, but it wasn’t before I was engulfed in multiple crises that I started understanding how I should act. At the same time as I was experiencing a crisis of responsibility as the director of an institution, my child was having behavioural problems in school, which led me to another crisis, a parenting one. I finally left the CIAP in April 2021, in order to devote myself entirely to leading a better life and to loving differently.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">I have now joined a collective organisation – which is still embryonic and imperfect, due to the fact that it is constantly evolving – because I believe it is the best thing I can do in the face of the environmental crisis on my own level, that is, based on my current experience and means. Here, my comrades offer me sensitive and intellectual support which helps me see through the scam of green transition. By contrast, I recognise the potential of small-scale action by working from a broader criticism of the capitalist production model. For me, this is one of the conditions for operating a paradigm shift and moving away from the model that Western patriarchal modernity has imposed on us for centuries. In concrete terms, this demands that I move out of my comfort zone in order to transform <em>myself</em>, by learning about autonomy and communisation, two vital aspects which I had neglected until then. Now, with others, I am imagining a form of food-producing agriculture that will be able, on the long term, to feed dozens in the area, as well as a way of cultivating and farming that fosters sharing with <em>more-than-humans</em>. On a broader scale, I am trying to contribute to a project that to me seems like it could become an inspiring model for exchanging with other groups, through the networked transmission of forms of knowledge and experimentations, not at the margins of society but in permanent connection with beings, the earth and the world.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Artistically, I feel a greater freedom than in my previous occupation, even though, during those twenty years, I did try to find my way into the interstices that the profession offered: attempting to express, from the margins of the exhibition, ideas from outside the frame, from places of latency and emergence, embracing the partly hidden meanings that could appear in these spatial and temporal intervals, and manifesting the unexpected connections between different artworks. These approaches were so invisible that only a few friends from the contemporary art world followed me down this path – Gyan Panchal, Caroline Ferreira, Anne Bonnin, Simone Menegoi, Marjorie Micucci and Cécilia Becanovic. I am grateful to them for sharing their emotions with me; without them I would have collapsed a lot sooner!</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Now, I let myself try things out without worrying beforehand whether they are art or not. These days, whatever I create, I create with pleasure, particularly because I am producing things for my friends: a poster to advertise the spring cleaning of our community centre, an invitation to the collective potato harvest, etc. And when I am asked to contribute to a contemporary art catalogue, now I am brave enough to send in a drawing, embracing its illustrative function and its non-referenced style.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <blockquote>Isn’t ecological art amateur by definition? Devoid of any professional aim, ecological art should be integrated into our everyday existences, and should reach out to all areas of life.</blockquote>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>It should be useful in the same way applied arts are, but also in the sense that all art forms – even when they are created for no particular purpose – seem to be universally useful, if only because they transform our perception of the world.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Another characteristic of this deeply ecological art I so much want to see materialise is that it is an art of the common, in other words, an art created in the service of a common cause, for a group or a village. Yet at present, most artists create objects individually, which, in the best-case scenario, will then be shown publicly. Although cultural policies increasingly incentivise displaying artworks to “audiences” in order to justify public spending on the arts (which represents barely 1% of France’s global budget), I have often noticed that making an artwork public, exhibiting it, organising Q&amp;A sessions with the artist, and so on, does not necessarily go hand in hand with the communisation of art, despite the best efforts of the professionals involved. The examples of art of the commons that I have taken part in recently are very different in this respect, because they are planned by the artists in co-creation with amateur groups: a parade for the Day of the Dead performed by a group of ten locals and initiated by Cellule d’Actions Rituelles in 2019, an installation of food cooked in ovens built for the occasion in a public building by Doriane Albert and Anna Gianferrari (of the <em>FEU </em>association) in 2021, an altar for the dead created collectively and accessible 24 hours a day…[note]<span lang="EN-GB">All these performances took place in the village of Faux-la-Montagne (Plateau de Millevaches) during the Samhain festivities organised by the association <i>Par la racine</i>, which guides local communities in their relationship to death.</span>[/note] Artists offer their talent to the community, sometimes anonymously, and they accept that the end result no longer belongs to them. Note how these forms of art of the common are ecological in the sense that they are precisely located in space and time. They happen locally, becoming important moments in the life of the individuals or groups taking part in their realisation (unlike unknown viewers who discover artworks once they are finished).</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Lastly, deeply ecological art should be connected to the earth and to <em>more-than-human</em> beings, not as a theme (i.e. an artwork dealing with agriculture) or as a skill (i.e. the art of agriculture). It should be completely integrated into cultivation practices. From the space I inhabit, when I examine the different agricultural methods at my disposal, biodynamic farming seems to ideally connect the gestures of cultivation with the microbiological and cosmic levels. In a field so drastically affected by the mind/body, subject/object dichotomies, which have become all the more flagrant in the wake of industrial agriculture and its irreversible consequences on all lifeforms, for the past century the biodynamic approach has been trying to recreate a connection between sensory perceptions and nurturing practices. When I started working as a farmer, this connection suddenly started seeming familiar, due to my knowledge of art history – through the historical links between the biodynamic approach and artistic practices ranging from dance to painting – and especially because of my interest in certain processes that are present in art and in agriculture alike, such as losing control, transitory states, incompletion, shapelessness…</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Earth-based energetic practices, which are less widespread in the cities where I worked (although they are fashionable there too – to a certain degree at least, since they are considered to be just as irrational as biodynamic farming is in academic and professional environments), open up approaches to some of the earth’s unexplained aspects – at least through the practices I can access in France right now: intuitive communication, geobiology, garden harmonisation, and so on. In these practices, sensorial experience is central. Unlike agricultural policies which focus only on hyperproduction, through the prism of energetic practices I can consider food-producing agriculture that is not only aimed at feeding me, a human, but at creating a balance between other visible and invisible beings. Wasn’t this exactly the dimension that interested me in contemporary art to begin with?</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Artists such as Suzanne Husky and Etienne de France have helped me envision a space for exchanges between art and farming: Suzanne through ecofeminism, Etienne through speculative fiction.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <blockquote>I now try to connect earth-based practices and art practices by drawing from energetic methods, considered as a bridge between two worlds that used to be separate.</blockquote>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>I can achieve this by cherry-picking techniques during courses, workshops and trainings, but my theoretical base is still shaky. Thanks to a conversation with Nicole Pignier,[note]A semiotician and researcher at the Limoges Faculty of Literature and Science, she has contributed to creating a school for the planetary garden alongside Gilles Clément and the Lycée agricole des Vaseix, in the form of a B.A. in “Aménagement paysager, design des milieux anthropisés” (Design and landscaping of anthropized environments). See her talk at the École nationale supérieure d’art de Limoges (ENSAD) during the seminar <em>Matière et architecture&nbsp;: de la terre au territoire</em>, October 2021, available at <a href="https://youtu.be/hfKDJHGCWMs">https://youtu.be/hfKDJHGCWMs</a> (last accessed 8 February 2023).[/note] I have been able to connect cultural and cultivation practices in a neatly conceptual way. Based on the works of Augustin Berque, Pignier foregrounds a co-articulation of the living through the gestures of farming. The accounts of the farmers she introduced us to, and that she recorded talking about their relationship to livestock and garden farming gave me a great deal of hope for the future of our world.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p style="font-weight: 400;">Working on a fruit and tree farm armed with my artistic perspective, I consider each plant and tree simultaneously as a singular being and as part of a whole. For the first time, I have encountered the earth, which holds minerals, vegetables, animals, living and dead creatures, some of which will remain foreign to me forever. Earth gives, even when we don’t know how to give back. I have only just begun imagining a form of ecology stemming from art.[note]For further information, see Marie-Anne Lanavère “Marianne Lanavère jette son costume de directrice aux orties&nbsp;(entretien avec Émilie Renard)”, <em>Lili, </em>no. 3, 2021, p. 122-128, <a href="https://www.la-criee.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/REVUE_3_WEB_page.pdf">https://www.la-criee.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/REVUE_3_WEB_page.pdf</a> (Last visited: 8.2.2023), and Manon Simons, <em>La part invisible</em>, film for Télémillevaches, 2021, 16 min., <a href="https://telemillevaches.net/videos/la-part-invisible/">https://telemillevaches.net/videos/la-part-invisible/</a> (last accessed 8 February 2023).[/note]</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>&nbsp;</p>\r\n
              """
            "format" => "rich_text_2"
          ]
        ]
        "x-default" => array:1 [
          0 => array:2 [
            "value" => """
              <p>Dans l’art contemporain, un secteur professionnel basé sur l’économie de marché globalisée, et où j’ai travaillé pendant plus de vingt ans comme chargée de production, commissaire d’exposition, puis directrice, principalement en institutions publiques, la conscience écologique n’a guidé mes choix que très tardivement. La priorité était généralement donnée à la production du projet de l’artiste, à sa diffusion et à sa transmission, sans que le paradigme écologique n’interfère, ou si peu, dans la liberté de créer et de programmer. Comme les entreprises privées, dans les années 2000, les institutions ont bien dû, elles aussi, se mettre au parfum de la RSO[note]<i><span lang="FR">(NdE) </span></i><span lang="FR">La Responsabilité Sociétale des Organisations (RSO) est la gestion, par une entité, des impacts économiques, sociaux et environnementaux de ses activités.</span>[/note], des chartes et normes ISO diverses, tantôt par esprit de compétitivité, par bonne conscience, ou tout simplement par conformisme. Plutôt que de risquer de renverser l’ensemble du système, les structures culturelles ont compris comment se délester d’une conscientisation écologique, qui les aurait nécessairement bouleversées en profondeur. L’une des échappatoires fut de sous-traiter la question via des agences de conseil, ou de coaching environnemental. Plus largement, les fondations, biennales et institutions que je considérais comme les plus pointues et en phase avec les enjeux de société actuels ont réussi, selon un tour de passe-passe, à aborder l’écologie comme objet extérieur d’étude, plutôt que comme mécanisme interne à questionner. Partant généralement d’intentions bienveillantes, le fait d’organiser des séminaires de recherche, des résidences et des expositions non pas <em>avec</em>, mais <em>sur</em> (<em>à propos de</em>) l’écologie, continue, aujourd’hui, à dédouaner ces structures de penser véritablement un fonctionnement écologique de l’art. De manière perverse, et sans même s’en rendre compte, elles participent, à leur manière, d’un système qui ne prend pas acte de l’urgence du changement, et qui repousse sans cesse l’échéance du dépassement planétaire.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Dans ce paysage, il y a bien des chemins de traverse qui rendent l’action possible, mais ces espoirs demandent de renoncer à certains acquis. En effet, la démarche écologique implique nécessairement d’abandonner une partie de ce qu’on s’est construit pendant de nombreuses années, voire tout ce qu’on avait capitalisé&nbsp;: position sociale valorisante, réseaux, privilèges… Un processus fort difficile à amorcer par les milieux professionnels, qui mettent déjà toute leur énergie à défendre au mieux la création et à négocier longuement, et sur un mode syndical, des droits statutaires pour les artistes et les équipes des structures, encore majoritairement précaires. Or, pendant ce temps – tout ce temps que j’ai passé à militer de cette façon-là – je constate finalement que l’art, dans ce qu’il a d’essentiel à mes yeux — en tant qu’il relève de la poïétique, de la présence et de la rencontre — continue à être en recul dans la société libérale. Toujours plus méprisé, l’art est pourtant incapable de sortir du paradigme capitaliste, qui n’accorde de valeur qu’à la production, au degré de marchandisation et au potentiel médiatique.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <blockquote>Pourtant, l’espoir surgit sporadiquement dans les lieux d’art, à travers des manières de travailler profondément écologiques, et incarnées singulièrement par des personnes qui résistent au quotidien à leurs financeurs, leur hiérarchie, voire à leurs collègues, et qui savent par moment dire «&nbsp;non&nbsp;» aux artistes elleux-mêmes, si talentueux·euses soient-iels, dès lors que liberté de création se met à rimer avec libéralisme.</blockquote>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Inscrire le travail de l’art dans une démarche d’écologie profonde, qui ne se réduirait pas à l’usage de matériaux labellisés — de type «&nbsp;PEFC&nbsp;» pour le papier[note]<i><span lang="FR">(NdE) </span></i><span lang="FR">Le Programme de reconnaissance des certifications forestières (PEFC) est un organisme international de certification forestière, dont la mission est de garantir une gestion durable des forêts, au moyen d’un label s’appliquant aux propriétaires forestiers, aux exploitants et aux entreprises de la filière forêt-bois-papier.</span>[/note] — demande, au préalable, de prendre conscience de la perte de sens induite par la production artistique elle-même, notamment sur le terrain des ressources qui lui sont nécessaires&nbsp;: d’où viennent les matériaux avec lesquels je travaille&nbsp;? Comment je les transforme&nbsp;? Que deviendront-ils une fois modifiés&nbsp;? Or, faire des choix responsables est devenu pratiquement impossible dans les métropoles, plaques tournantes des échanges commerciaux, où tout transite de partout et de nulle part, du moment que je paye. Alors que les villes sont <em>déterrestrées</em>, et qu’y habiter relève de la survie, c’est là que continuent à se développer les pôles d’activités, notamment culturels, et c’est donc là que vivent la plupart des artistes professionnel·le·x·s, par engrenage précaire ou manque d’alternative. Quelques lignes de William Morris énonçaient déjà, il y a plus d’un siècle en Angleterre, que la conscience du matériau s’était perdue, pas tant à cause de l’industrialisation elle-même que de la division des tâches visant à plus de productivité : «&nbsp;Si un arbre est abattu ou déraciné, si tant est que ça soit possible, on en plantera un pire à sa place. [...] La substance même, dont se nourrissent les arts supérieurs et inférieurs, a été détruite. Le puits de l’art est empoisonné à sa source&nbsp;».[note]<span lang="FR">William </span><span lang="FR">Morris, «&nbsp;L’art en ploutocratie [conférence à l’Université d’Oxford]&nbsp;» [1883], dans W. Morris, <i>L’Art et l’artisanat</i>(W. Morris), Paris, Payot &amp; Rivages, 2011, p. 61.</span>[/note]</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Plus récents, et agissant politiquement sur un autre terrain — celui d’une sensibilité en crise — les écrits de l’anthropologue américain David Abram peuvent, quant à eux, nous aider à repenser un rapport au matériau non pas comme ressource exploitable, mais comme présence&nbsp;:</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p><mark class="question">«&nbsp;Bien sûr nos artefacts humains conservent inévitablement un élément d’altérité <em>plus-qu’humaine</em>. Cette altérité, que nous ne pouvons ni connaître ni nous approprier, réside le plus souvent dans les matériaux dont ces objets sont faits […]. L’art véritable, pourrait-on dire, est simplement une création humaine qui n’étouffe pas l’élément non-humain mais permet à ce qui est Autre dans les matériaux de continuer à vivre et à respirer&nbsp;».[note]<span lang="FR">David </span><span lang="FR">Abram, <i>Comment la terre s’est tue. Pour une écologie des sens</i>, Paris, La Découverte, 2013, p. 91-92.</span>[/note]</mark></p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Dans un contexte de production et de diffusion d’un art contemporain qui aliène (au lieu de favoriser une rencontre avec l’art comme altérité), trouver une façon de nous relier aux matériaux, en tant que présences, nous permettrait, ainsi, non seulement de mieux habiter la terre, mais d’être aussi habité·e·x·s par elle.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Parallèlement à cette conscience de l’usage des matériaux, l’écologie profonde pourrait également se traduire dans la manière dont l’équipe d’un lieu culturel travaille avec les artistes qu’elle invite à exposer ou à travailler en résidence. En effet, il n’est pas rare de constater que certain·e·x·s artistes du secteur professionnel de l’art contemporain –&nbsp;souffrant elleux-mêmes d’être exploité·e·x·s – procèdent, sans s’en rendre compte, selon une forme d’extractivisme. À cet égard, j’ai fréquemment ressenti de la gêne lorsque les artistes s’inspirent de savoirs artisanaux, comme l’herboristerie de plantes médicinales, ou de savoirs indigènes occidentaux (sourciers, druides, guérisseuses d’aujourd’hui), lorsqu’iels «&nbsp;volent&nbsp;» des savoirs sans rien apporter en échange, en puisant un maximum d’inspiration et de techniques, ou tout simplement lorsqu’iels veulent aller trop vite, en consommateur·rice·x·s, dans leur appréhension d’un territoire. Ces mécanismes, douloureux à formuler, quand bien même on souhaite soutenir les artistes et respecter leur travail, je les ai partagés pendant neuf ans à la direction du Centre International d’Art et du Paysage (CIAP) de l’île de Vassivière, en premier lieu avec l’équipe. Nous discutions ensemble de nos limites et de nos paradoxes. Ces réflexions ont pu se développer dans la durée, au travers du compagnonnage avec des artistes ouvert·e·x·s au débat&nbsp;; je pense notamment à Tiphaine Calmettes, Etienne de France, François Génot, Suzanne Husky, L’amicale mille feux, RADO, Liliana Rojas Sanchez, Natsuko Uchino, ainsi qu’aux chercheur·euse·x·s Cristina Consuegra et Alexis Zimmer, L’école de la terre ou encore à mes collègues directeur·ice·x·s d’autres centres d’art telles que Béatrice Josse et Émilie Renard.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>C’est d’abord en apprenant à vivre dans sa propre région que l’équipe de Vassivière a pu de mieux en mieux guider les artistes vers une compréhension plus fine du territoire. Transmettre une manière locale de vivre afin de changer les façons de travailler des artistes, n’est-ce pas là œuvrer pour une écologie de l’art&nbsp;? Il ne s’agit ici pas uniquement de s’inspirer de ce que les habitant·e·x·s portent comme histoires et cultures, mais aussi de les respecter jusqu’à parfois préférer garder secret certains savoirs indigènes et vernaculaires, auquel l’accès est un long chemin et qui exigerait un temps plus conséquent de résidence, ou que l’artiste revienne plusieurs fois sur place afin de continuer sa recherche.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <blockquote>Vivre et travailler écologiquement dans un lieu, c’est réaffirmer une échelle locale longtemps délaissée dans l’art contemporain, dépasser une attitude néocoloniale très courante dans ses pratiques professionnelles, déconstruire les mécanismes complexes de pouvoir entre grosses institutions et petites associations dans chaque région.</blockquote>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Plus spécifiquement, dans un territoire rural comme Vassivière, une approche écologique exige d’être à l’écoute des réalités fines du territoire pour ne pas dominer les savoirs populaires, ou moins visibles, et ne pas imposer le prisme de l’art contemporain, citadin et globalisé. À mon échelle et à celle du CIAP, freiner la commande de nouvelles œuvres d’art dans l’espace public après 30 années d’accumulation au sein du parc de sculptures, m’a semblé être une des manières de travailler écologiquement. Avant même que je ne candidate au poste de directrice, ces œuvres pérennes en plein air m’apparaissaient comme des formes de pollution, au service d’une attractivité touristique imposée à cette île <em>hors-sol</em>, dont le devenir était décidé sans concertation locale. À ce sujet, mes longues discussions, dès 2014, avec Benoît Antille de l’École de Design et Haute Ecole d’Art du Valais (ÉDHÉA), à partir de sa critique de l’économie de projet dans les parcs à sculptures et les commandes artistiques dans la nature m’ont particulièrement aidée à questionner le fonctionnement d’un lieu artistique en milieu rural[note]Benoît Antille mène actuellement une recherche doctorale intitulée <i>The artist as expert : a critical analysis of the projet economy&nbsp;</i>à l’Université d’Amsterdam.[/note]. Ces discussions se sont poursuivies au sein du colloque <em>L’art dans l’espace rural</em>où je l’avais invité en 2017 au CIAP, jusqu’au séminaire <em>The Rural&nbsp;Assembly</em> à la Whitechapel Gallery de Londres (2019)[note]<i><span lang="EN-US">The Rural Assembly: Contemporary Art and Spaces of Connection </span></i><span style="color: var(--bs-body-color); font-family: var(--bs-body-font-family); font-size: var(--bs-body-font-size); text-align: var(--bs-body-text-align); background-color: var(--bs-body-bg);">[séminaire], Whitechapel Gallery, Londres, 20-22 juin 2019.</span>[/note], auquel nous avons assisté ensemble, et qui m’a permis de résoudre intellectuellement certains nœuds quant à la justesse de la position à adopter face à ces questions.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Parmi tous les paradoxes et les tentatives de repositionnement qui m’ont traversée ces dernières années en travaillant dans un contexte géographique marqué par l’exploitation des ressources (lacs de barrage et forêts industrielles du Plateau de Millevaches) et par des politiques publiques de classement/protection/réserve des espaces «&nbsp;naturels&nbsp;», je me suis aperçue que ce n’est pas forcément à l’endroit où l’on croit pouvoir agir de manière écologique, qu’on peut profondément le faire. Au niveau d’un centre d’art comme celui de Vassivière, dans la préparation d’une exposition par exemple, il m’apparaissait ainsi plus durable de consacrer du temps à échanger avec la population, écouter ses désirs quant à ce lieu, de mutualiser les moyens afin d’opérer une forme de redistribution des richesses, de permettre aux artistes et à l’équipe d’approfondir une recherche... quitte à faire moins d’expositions par an, à moins voyager, ou à faire le choix de ponctuellement ne pas être exemplaire sur la biodégradabilité des matériaux.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Finalement, adresser les urgences écologiques contemporaines à partir de l’art, reviendrait, en réalité, à réapprendre à vivre, en considérant l’apprentissage d’un nouveau métier&nbsp;: celui de vivre justement (et de mourir). Dans cette approche holistique, le lieu, la nature, soi-même et les autres sont mis en relation. Cela demande d’écouter, de multiplier les attentions, de faire ensemble. Cela demande surtout de développer, à l’opposé de la prédominance théorique, une perception sensorielle d’un monde <em>plus-qu’humain</em> — pour reprendre l’expression de David Abram. Prendre soin de la terre et du vivant dans chacune de nos activités, y compris en ville, relève, en effet, d'un rapport cosmogonique que nous avons parfois perdu en Occident, et que nous sommes invité·e·x·s à réinvestir, notamment en s’inspirant de cultures indigènes et autochtones d’ailleurs. Les Rencontres de la Ferme de Lachaud (Plateau de Millevaches), auxquelles je prends part chaque année depuis que je vis en Limousin, m’ont permis de découvrir et de m’inspirer de la pensée d’anthropologues et de philosophes de la nature, sans pour autant que je sache traduire ces pistes concrètement dans ma vie, jusqu’à très récemment. Grâce à la parution en français, notamment aux éditions Cambourakis, de textes fondateurs de l’approche éco-féministe, j’ai pu renouer avec des paganismes occidentaux, et ainsi trouver des formes vivantes, notamment rituelles et plastiques, ici et maintenant, au lieu d’aller les chercher ailleurs. C’est dans cet esprit que j’avais, depuis le CIAP de Vassivière et ailleurs, co-organisé de nombreuses rencontres.[note]Voir notamment les journées d’étude intitulées «&nbsp;Habité·e / Être habité·e&nbsp;: quelles relations au vivant&nbsp;?&nbsp;» à Eymoutiers et à Cieux (Limousin) en mai 2019, organisées avec Nicole Pigner, l’École de la terre, et le Cercle Gramsci de Limoges. Voir aussi la visite de Barbara Glowczewski et Geneviève Pruvost au CIAP avec leurs étudiant·e·x·s de l’École des hautes études en sciences sociales (EHESS), pour rencontrer des guérisseur·euse·x·s locaux·ales, visite qui a mené à une recherche sensible publiée dans l’ouvrage collectif <em>Des énergies qui soignent en Montagne limousine&nbsp;: Enquête collective </em>(Geneviève Pruvost et Barbara Glowczewski, Lamazière-Basse, Maïade éditions, 2021).[/note]</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Le changement de paradigme dont le monde occidental a tant besoin aujourd’hui pour sortir de sa crise, suppose d’être capable, parallèlement à la lutte politique, de se transformer soi-même à l’échelle individuelle à tous les niveaux&nbsp;: dans son rapport au sensible, à l’autre, à la sexualité, à l’amour, à la nature, etc. Prendre ce risque est une mise en danger parfois douloureuse, qui ne peut pas se faire sans renoncer à certains de mes privilèges, pour mieux faire exister d’autres attachements auxquels je tiens vraiment.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p><mark class="question">«&nbsp;C’est qu’il ne s’agit plus de reprendre ou d’infléchir un système de production, mais de sortir de la production comme principe unique de rapport au monde […]. D’où l’importance capitale d’utiliser ce temps de confinement imposé pour décrire, d’abord chacun pour soi, puis en groupe, ce à quoi nous sommes attachés&nbsp;;&nbsp;ce dont nous sommes prêts à nous libérer&nbsp;;&nbsp;les chaînes que nous sommes prêts à reconstituer et celles que, par notre comportement, nous sommes décidés à interrompre.&nbsp;»[note]<span lang="FR">Bruno </span><span lang="FR">Latour, «&nbsp;Imaginer les gestes-barrières contre le retour à la production d’avant-crise&nbsp;», <i>AOC,</i> 29 mars 2020, </span><span lang="FR"><a href="http://www.bruno-latour.fr/fr/node/849">http://www.bruno-latour.fr/fr/node/849</a></span><span lang="FR">&nbsp;(dernière consultation le 2.8.2023).</span>[/note] </mark></p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>C’est ce que le philosophe Bruno Latour nous invitait à faire lors du premier confinement imposé en France pendant la pandémie de Covid-19 en 2020, à travers ce texte suivi d’ateliers participatifs intitulés <em>Où Atterrir</em>, créés avec S-composition[note]<i><span lang="FR">(NdE) </span></i>S-composition est une compagnie créée en 2004 par le compositeur et metteur en scène Jean-Pierre Seyvos&nbsp;: <span lang="FR"><a href="https://s-composition.eu/">https://s-composition.eu/</a></span> (dernière consultation le 3.10.2023).[/note] à la Mégisserie de Saint-Junien, à proximité de Limoges, et ailleurs.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Si cet appel, en agissant comme un déclencheur dans les milieux culturels, m’a indéniablement aidée personnellement à franchir le cap, j’ai eu besoin qu’il s’incarne plus précisément dans des formes de récits qui touchaient davantage ma sensibilité. Le récit bouleversant de l’anthropologue Nastassja Martin (2019) m’a ainsi paru exemplaire dans l’adéquation révolutionnaire qu’elle parvient à opérer entre son style poétique d’écriture, son sujet d’étude — le peuple Évène en Sibérie — et sa propre transformation, pas seulement en tant que chercheuse, mais aussi en tant qu’individu dans son rapport au réel[note]<span lang="FR">Nastassja </span><span lang="FR">Martin, <i>Croire aux fauves</i>, Paris, Gallimard, 2019.</span>[/note]. Plus près de nous géographiquement, l’artiste-chercheur Boris Nordmann mène depuis 2017 avec l’association Quartier Rouge de Felletin (Creuse), des ateliers au cours desquels le travail du corps humain répond à l’observation de comportements animaux, parallèlement à un travail d’écriture, où son expérience subjective se mêle à des considérations anthropologiques. Sa «&nbsp;fiction corporelle&nbsp;» <em>Lou Pastoral</em> risque une mise en danger de lui-même au contact de son sujet de recherche, mise en danger similaire à celle de Nastassja Martin, tout en réussissant à incarner dans des formes corporelles, la nécessité d’un retournement du point de vue.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Au moment de la parution du texte de Latour susmentionné «&nbsp;Imaginer les gestes-barrières contre le retour à la production d’avant-crise&nbsp;», j’étais toujours en poste au CIAP de Vassivière, et cela faisait un moment qu’au lieu de m’intéresser à l’art pour changer le monde, je prenais conscience que pour changer le monde, il fallait changer ma vie, réduire mes besoins matériels, mais aussi être plus à l’écoute des besoins de mes proches, et des autres êtres <em>plus-qu’humains</em>. L’équipe m’avait déjà demandé de ralentir le rythme des expositions, avant même le confinement, mais il m’a fallu être moi-même en multi-crises pour comprendre enfin comment agir&nbsp;! La crise de responsabilité que je vivais en tant que directrice d’une institution s’accompagnait simultanément de difficultés comportementales de mon enfant à l’école, qui m’amenaient vers une autre crise, celle de la parentalité, avant que je ne quitte finalement l’institution artistique en avril 2021, pour me consacrer entièrement à mieux vivre, et aimer autrement.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Aujourd’hui, si j’ai rejoint des formes diverses d'organisations sur le Plateau de Millevaches, si balbutiantes et imparfaites soient-elles — car en construction permanente — c’est car j’estime que c’est la meilleure chose que je peux faire pour répondre à la crise écologique, et ce, à mon niveau, c’est-à-dire avec mon expérience et mes moyens actuels. Je trouve ici, parmi les camarades, des appuis sensibles et intellectuels, qui me permettent de dépasser l’arnaque de la transition écologique. <em>A contrario,</em> j’entrevois la possibilité d’agir à une petite échelle, certes, mais à partir d’une remise en question plus globale au préalable du modèle de production capitaliste. C’est pour moi une condition pour opérer un changement de paradigme et s’éloigner du modèle imposé par la modernité occidentale patriarcale depuis des siècles. Concrètement, cela me demande de sortir de ma zone de confort pour me transformer moi-même en apprenant à la fois l’autonomie et la mise en commun, deux facettes vitales dont j’avais pu me passer jusque-là. Aujourd’hui, je pense, avec d’autres, une agriculture vivrière capable à terme de nourrir plusieurs dizaines de personnes du voisinage, ainsi qu’une manière de cultiver et d’élever qui favorise davantage le partage avec les <em>plus-qu’humains</em>. Plus largement, j’essaye de contribuer à un projet de vie qui me paraît pouvoir devenir un modèle inspirant à partir duquel échanger avec d’autres groupes, transmettre en réseaux des savoirs et des expérimentations, non pas en marge de la société, mais en lien permanent avec les êtres, la terre et le monde.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Sur le plan artistique, je ressens une plus grande liberté que celle que mon ancien métier m’octroyait. J’ai pourtant tenté pendant vingt ans, tant bien que mal, de m’immiscer dans les interstices que m’offraient ma profession&nbsp;: exprimer, depuis les marges des accrochages, une pensée du hors-champ, de la latence et du surgissement, défendre la part de significations cachées, qui pourraient émerger dans les intervalles spatiaux et temporels d’une exposition, rendre publiques des correspondances sensibles, mais insoupçonnées, d’une œuvre à une autre… Des démarches tellement peu visibles que seule une poignée d’ami·e·x·s de l’art contemporain me suivaient dans ces chemins-là – Gyan Panchal, Caroline Ferreira, Anne Bonnin, Simone Menegoi, Marjorie Micucci, ou encore Cécilia Becanovic. Je les remercie d’avoir su partager leurs émotions, sans quoi j’aurais sombré bien plus rapidement&nbsp;!</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Je m’autorise désormais des pratiques sans avoir besoin de savoir si elles relèvent de l’art ou non. Ce que je crée aujourd’hui, je le fais avec beaucoup de plaisir, notamment parce que je m’adresse à un cercle amical&nbsp;: une affiche pour annoncer le nettoyage de printemps de la maison d’accueil, une invitation pour la récolte collective de pommes de terre, etc. Et lorsqu’on me demande de participer à un catalogue d’art contemporain, j’ose dorénavant proposer un dessin, en assumant sa fonction illustrative et son style non référencé.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <blockquote>Un art écologique ne serait-il donc pas un art nécessairement amateur&nbsp;? Sans visée professionnelle, cet art serait à la fois intégré dans la vie quotidienne et s’étendrait à tous les domaines de la vie.</blockquote>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Il serait utile au sens où peuvent l’être les arts dit appliqués, mais aussi dans le sens où toute forme d’art, parfois réalisée sans intention, me paraît avoir une utilité en toute situation, ne serait-ce que parce qu’elle transforme notre sensibilité au monde.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Autre caractéristique de cet art profondément écologique que j’aimerais tant voir advenir&nbsp;: un art du commun, c’est-à-dire un art créé au service d’une cause commune, pour un groupe, un village… Or, actuellement, la plupart des artistes créent de manière individuelle des objets qui, dans les meilleurs des cas, sont ensuite rendus publics. Alors qu’il y a de plus en plus d’injonction des politiques culturelles à montrer l’œuvre à un «&nbsp;public&nbsp;» afin de justifier des dépenses liées à la création artistique (dépenses qui représentent pourtant à peine 1&nbsp;% du budget global de l’État en France), j’ai souvent observé que rendre publique une œuvre, l’exposer, organiser une rencontre avec l’artiste, etc., ne s’accompagnait pas pour autant d’une mise en commun de l’art, et ce, malgré tous les efforts des professionnel·le·x·s. Les exemples d’art du commun auxquels j’ai participé ces dernières années sont bien différents, car pensés en amont par les artistes en co-création avec un groupe amateur&nbsp;: un défilé pour la fête des morts performé en 2019 par une dizaine d’habitant·e·x·s et animé par la Cellule d’Actions Rituelles&nbsp;;&nbsp;une installation de nourritures cuites sur des fours spécialement créés pour l’occasion dans un bâtiment public par Doriane Albert &amp; Anna Gianferrari (association <em>FEU</em>) en 2021&nbsp;;&nbsp;un autel des morts créé collectivement dans le village et accessible jour et nuit[note]<span lang="FR">Toutes ces formes se sont déroulées à Faux-la-Montagne (Plateau de Millevaches) dans le cadre du Samaïn organisé par l’association <i>Par la racine</i>, qui accompagne les habitant·e·x·s dans leur rapport à la mort.</span>[/note]… Les artistes mettent au service d’une communauté leur talent, parfois de manière anonyme, en acceptant que le résultat leur échappe. Remarquons combien ces formes d’art du commun sont écologiques dans le sens où elles sont situées dans l’espace et le temps. Elles adviennent localement pour marquer des moments importants dans la vie d’individus ou de groupes&nbsp; qui participent à toutes les étapes de leurs création (à la différence d’un public inconnu et distant de l’artiste, qui découvre l’œuvre une fois réalisée).</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Enfin, un art profondément écologique serait celui qui se lie à la terre et aux êtres <em>plus-qu’humains</em>, non pas en tant que thématique (ex. un art qui parle d’agriculture), ni en tant que savoir-faire (ex. l’art de l’agriculture). Il s’agirait d’un art complètement intégré dans les pratiques culturales, celles de cultiver. Lorsque je regarde, depuis là où j’habite, les différentes méthodes qui s’offrent à moi en agriculture, la biodynamie me paraît connecter de manière exemplaire les gestes de cultiver aux échelles microbiologiques et cosmiques. Dans un secteur qui souffre tant des séparations corps/esprit, sujet/objet, etc., séparations devenues d’autant plus criantes dans le sillage de l’agriculture industrielle et dont les conséquences sur l’ensemble des vivants sont irréversibles, l’approche biodynamique tente depuis un siècle de retisser des correspondances entre les perceptions sensorielles et les pratiques nourricières. À partir du moment où je me suis mise à cultiver moi-même, ces correspondances m’ont paru soudain familières, du fait de mes connaissances en histoire de l’art — des liens historiques de la biodynamie avec les pratiques artistiques allant de la danse à la peinture — et surtout de ma sensibilité pour certains processus qu’on peut retrouver en art, comme en agriculture, tels que la perte de contrôle, les états transitoires, l’inachèvement, l’informe...</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Moins répandues dans les métropoles où je travaillais (quoi qu’à la mode... jusqu’à un certain point, car jugées tout autant irrationnelles que la biodynamie par les milieux académiques et professionnels), les pratiques énergétiques liées à la terre permettent d’en approcher la part inexpliquée. Du moins pour celles auxquelles je peux avoir accès en France en ce moment&nbsp;: communication intuitive, géobiologie, harmonisation du jardin, etc. Là encore, ces démarches accordent une importance à l’expérience des sens. Contrairement aux politiques agricoles uniquement orientées vers l’hyperproduction, je peux envisager, grâce au prisme des pratiques énergétiques, une production vivrière non pas uniquement destinée à me nourrir, moi humaine, mais vécue dans un équilibre avec d’autres êtres, visibles et invisibles. Cette dimension n’est-elle pas justement celle qui m’intéressait tant dans l’art contemporain&nbsp;?</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Des artistes tels que Suzanne Husky et Etienne de France m’ont aidée à imaginer un espace d’échanges entre art et agriculture&nbsp;: Suzanne par le biais de l’écoféminisme, Etienne par celui de la fiction spéculative.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <blockquote>Aujourd’hui, j’essaye, dans ma vie, d’articuler pratiques de la terre et pratiques artistiques, en m’appuyant sur des pratiques énergétiques, comme autant de passerelles entre deux mondes qui demeuraient séparés.</blockquote>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>Je peux le faire de manière pratique en picorant par-ci et par-là, dans des stages, ateliers et formations, mais mes appuis théoriques restent encore rares dans ce domaine. C’est à partir de conversations avec Nicole Pignier[note]<span lang="FR">Sémioticienne et chercheuse à la Faculté des sciences et lettres de Limoges (France). Elle a contribué à créer, avec le paysagiste Gilles Clément et le Lycée agricole des Vaseix, une école du jardin planétaire, sous forme d’une Licence «&nbsp;Aménagement paysager, design des milieux anthropisés&nbsp;». Voir sa conférence à l’École nationale supérieure d’art de Limoges (ENSAD) </span><span lang="FR">dans le cadre des journées d’étude <i>Matière et architecture&nbsp;: de la terre au territoire</i>, octobre 2021, </span><span lang="FR"><a href="https://youtu.be/hfKDJHGCWMs">https://youtu.be/hfKDJHGCWMs</a></span><span lang="FR"> (dernière consultation le 2.8.2023).</span>[/note] que j’ai pu conceptuellement articuler avec précision pratiques culturelles et pratiques culturales. En s’appuyant sur les écrits d’Augustin Berque, elle met en évidence une co-énonciation du vivant à travers les gestes paysans. Les paroles des paysan·ne·x·s qu’elle nous a fait rencontrer et qu’elle a enregistrées, à propos de leur relation au maraîchage et à l’élevage, m’ont donné beaucoup d’espoir quant à l’avenir de notre monde.</p>\r\n
              \r\n
              <p>En travaillant à une agriculture fruitière et arboricole depuis mon point de vue artistique, je considère chaque plante, chaque arbre, à la fois dans sa singularité et faisant partie d’un tout. Je rencontre pour la première fois une terre qui accueille minéraux, végétaux, animaux, êtres vivants et morts, dont certains me resteront étrangers. Une terre qui nous donne, même quand nous ne savons pas lui donner. Je peux tout juste commencer à penser une écologie à partir de l’art[note]<span lang="FR">Pour aller plus loin, voir Marie-Anne </span><span lang="FR">Lanavère «&nbsp;Marianne Lanavère jette son costume de directrice aux orties&nbsp;(entretien avec Émilie Renard)&nbsp;», <em>Lili</em>, n° 3, 2021<i> </i>pp. 122-128, </span><span lang="FR"><a href="https://www.la-criee.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/REVUE_3_WEB_page.pdf">https://www.la-criee.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/REVUE_3_WEB_page.pdf</a></span><span lang="FR">&nbsp;(dernière consultation le 2.8.2023), et </span><span lang="FR">Manon </span><span lang="FR">Simons, <i>La part invisible</i>, film pour Télémillevaches, 2021, 16 min., </span><span lang="FR"><a href="https://telemillevaches.net/videos/la-part-invisible/">https://telemillevaches.net/videos/la-part-invisible/</a></span>&nbsp;(dernière consultation le 2.8.2023).[/note]. &nbsp; &nbsp;</p>\r\n
              """
            "format" => "rich_text_2"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_post_trans_credit" => array:1 [
        "en" => array:1 [
          0 => array:1 [
            "value" => "Phoebe Hadjimarkos-Clarke"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_post_type" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => array:2 [
          0 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "152"
          ]
          1 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "148"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_subtitle" => array:2 [
        "en" => array:1 [
          0 => array:2 [
            "value" => "<p>Or, Ecology Stemming from Art</p>\r\n"
            "format" => "rich_text_1"
          ]
        ]
        "x-default" => array:1 [
          0 => array:2 [
            "value" => "<p>Ou l’écologie à partir de l’art</p>\r\n"
            "format" => "rich_text_1"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_tags" => array:1 [
        "x-default" => array:5 [
          0 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "91"
          ]
          1 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "121"
          ]
          2 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "88"
          ]
          3 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "111"
          ]
          4 => array:1 [
            "target_id" => "128"
          ]
        ]
      ]
      "field_title_displayed" => array:2 [
        "en" => array:1 [
          0 => array:2 [
            "value" => "<p>For a Deeply Ecological Art</p>\r\n"
            "format" => "rich_text_1"
          ]
        ]
        "x-default" => array:1 [
          0 => array:2 [
            "value" => "<p>Pour un art profondément écologique</p>\r\n"
            "format" => "rich_text_1"
          ]
        ]
      ]
    ]
    #fields: &51 array:25 [
      "field_authors" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &52 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#1907
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2016}
          #name: "field_authors"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2322 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &52 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#1907}
      ]
      "field_cover_image" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &53 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2324
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2018}
          #name: "field_cover_image"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2420 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &53 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2324}
      ]
      "field_date" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &54 Drupal\datetime\Plugin\Field\FieldType\DateTimeFieldItemList {#2422
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2019}
          #name: "field_date"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\datetime\Plugin\Field\FieldType\DateTimeItem {#2433 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &54 Drupal\datetime\Plugin\Field\FieldType\DateTimeFieldItemList {#2422}
      ]
      "field_departments" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &55 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2435
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2020}
          #name: "field_departments"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2543 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &55 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2435}
      ]
      "field_license" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &56 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2545
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2021}
          #name: "field_license"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2556 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &56 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2545}
      ]
      "field_og_description" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2561
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2022}
          #name: "field_og_description"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558
            #definition: Drupal\Core\Entity\TypedData\EntityDataDefinition {#2559
              #definition: array:1 [
                "constraints" => array:2 [ …2]
              ]
              #typedDataManager: null
              #propertyDefinitions: array:45 [
                "nid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1919}
                "uuid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1922}
                "vid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1925}
                "langcode" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1928}
                "type" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1931}
                "revision_timestamp" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1933}
                "revision_uid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1937}
                "revision_log" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1941}
                "status" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1945}
                "uid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1950}
                "title" => Drupal\Core\Field\Entity\BaseFieldOverride {#2014}
                "created" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1957}
                "changed" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1961}
                "promote" => Drupal\Core\Field\Entity\BaseFieldOverride {#2015}
                "sticky" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1970}
                "default_langcode" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1975}
                "revision_default" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1981}
                "revision_translation_affected" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1987}
                "metatag" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1993}
                "path" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1997}
                "menu_link" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2000}
                "content_translation_source" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2004}
                "content_translation_outdated" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2008}
                "field_authors" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2016}
                "field_citation" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2017}
                "field_cover_image" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2018}
                "field_date" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2019}
                "field_departments" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2020}
                "field_license" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2021}
                "field_og_description" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2022}
                "field_post_abstract" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2023}
                "field_post_embed_credit" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2024}
                "field_post_embed_url" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2025}
                "field_post_images_credit" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2026}
                "field_post_media_images" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2027}
                "field_post_media_sound" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2028}
                "field_post_media_video" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2029}
                "field_post_nature" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2030}
                "field_post_text" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2031}
                "field_post_trans_credit" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2032}
                "field_post_type" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2033}
                "field_related_publications" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2034}
                "field_subtitle" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2035}
                "field_tags" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2036}
                "field_title_displayed" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2037}
              ]
            }
            #name: null
            #parent: null
            #_serviceIds: []
            #_entityStorages: []
            #stringTranslation: null
            #typedDataManager: null
            #entity: Drupal\node\Entity\Node {#1821
              #entityTypeId: "node"
              #enforceIsNew: &2 null
              #typedData: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
              #cacheContexts: array:1 [
                0 => "languages:language_content"
              ]
              #cacheTags: []
              #cacheMaxAge: -1
              #_serviceIds: []
              #_entityStorages: []
              #values: &50 array:34 [&50]
              #fields: &51 array:25 [&51]
              #fieldDefinitions: array:45 [
                "nid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1919}
                "uuid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1922}
                "vid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1925}
                "langcode" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1928}
                "type" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1931}
                "revision_timestamp" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1933}
                "revision_uid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1937}
                "revision_log" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1941}
                "status" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1945}
                "uid" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1950}
                "title" => Drupal\Core\Field\Entity\BaseFieldOverride {#2014}
                "created" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1957}
                "changed" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1961}
                "promote" => Drupal\Core\Field\Entity\BaseFieldOverride {#2015}
                "sticky" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1970}
                "default_langcode" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1975}
                "revision_default" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1981}
                "revision_translation_affected" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1987}
                "metatag" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1993}
                "path" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1997}
                "menu_link" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2000}
                "content_translation_source" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2004}
                "content_translation_outdated" => Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#2008}
                "field_authors" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2016}
                "field_citation" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2017}
                "field_cover_image" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2018}
                "field_date" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2019}
                "field_departments" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2020}
                "field_license" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2021}
                "field_og_description" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2022}
                "field_post_abstract" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2023}
                "field_post_embed_credit" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2024}
                "field_post_embed_url" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2025}
                "field_post_images_credit" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2026}
                "field_post_media_images" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2027}
                "field_post_media_sound" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2028}
                "field_post_media_video" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2029}
                "field_post_nature" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2030}
                "field_post_text" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2031}
                "field_post_trans_credit" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2032}
                "field_post_type" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2033}
                "field_related_publications" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2034}
                "field_subtitle" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2035}
                "field_tags" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2036}
                "field_title_displayed" => Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2037}
              ]
              #languages: array:4 [
                "fr" => Drupal\Core\Language\Language {#1825
                  #name: "French"
                  #id: "fr"
                  #direction: "ltr"
                  #weight: -10
                  #locked: false
                }
                "en" => Drupal\Core\Language\Language {#1823
                  #name: "English"
                  #id: "en"
                  #direction: "ltr"
                  #weight: -9
                  #locked: false
                }
                "und" => Drupal\Core\Language\Language {#1824
                  #name: "Non spécifié"
                  #id: "und"
                  #direction: "ltr"
                  #weight: 2
                  #locked: true
                }
                "zxx" => Drupal\Core\Language\Language {#1630
                  #name: "Non applicable"
                  #id: "zxx"
                  #direction: "ltr"
                  #weight: 3
                  #locked: true
                }
              ]
              #langcodeKey: "langcode"
              #defaultLangcodeKey: "default_langcode"
              #activeLangcode: "en"
              #defaultLangcode: "fr"
              #translations: &63 array:2 [
                "x-default" => array:2 [
                  "status" => 1
                  "entity" => Drupal\node\Entity\Node {#1822}
                ]
                "en" => array:2 [
                  "status" => 1
                  "entity" => Drupal\node\Entity\Node {#1821}
                ]
              ]
              #translationInitialize: false
              #newRevision: &64 false
              #isDefaultRevision: &65 "1"
              #entityKeys: &66 array:4 [
                "bundle" => "post"
                "id" => "1764"
                "revision" => "3393"
                "uuid" => "81facfed-5875-4e70-834e-52b0ceb782e3"
              ]
              #translatableEntityKeys: &67 array:8 [
                "label" => array:1 [
                  "x-default" => "Pour un art profondément écologique"
                ]
                "langcode" => array:2 [
                  "x-default" => "fr"
                  "en" => "en"
                ]
                "status" => array:2 [
                  "x-default" => "1"
                  "en" => "1"
                ]
                "published" => array:2 [
                  "x-default" => "1"
                  "en" => "1"
                ]
                "uid" => array:1 [
                  "x-default" => "1"
                ]
                "owner" => array:1 [
                  "x-default" => "1"
                ]
                "default_langcode" => array:2 [
                  "x-default" => "1"
                  "en" => "0"
                ]
                "revision_translation_affected" => array:2 [
                  "x-default" => "1"
                  "en" => "1"
                ]
              ]
              #validated: false
              #validationRequired: false
              #loadedRevisionId: &68 "3393"
              #revisionTranslationAffectedKey: "revision_translation_affected"
              #enforceRevisionTranslationAffected: &69 []
              #isSyncing: &70 false
              +in_preview: null
            }
          }
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: []
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "field_post_abstract" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2562
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2023}
          #name: "field_post_abstract"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\text\Plugin\Field\FieldType\TextLongItem {#2575 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "field_post_embed_credit" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2577
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2024}
          #name: "field_post_embed_credit"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: []
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "field_post_embed_url" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &71 Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2579
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2025}
          #name: "field_post_embed_url"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: []
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &71 Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2579}
      ]
      "field_post_images_credit" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2581
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2026}
          #name: "field_post_images_credit"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: []
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "field_post_media_images" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &72 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2583
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2027}
          #name: "field_post_media_images"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: []
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &72 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2583}
      ]
      "field_post_media_sound" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &73 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2585
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2028}
          #name: "field_post_media_sound"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: []
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &73 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2585}
      ]
      "field_post_media_video" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &74 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2587
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2029}
          #name: "field_post_media_video"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: []
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &74 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2587}
      ]
      "field_post_nature" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &75 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2589
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2030}
          #name: "field_post_nature"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2600 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &75 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2589}
      ]
      "field_post_text" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2602
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2031}
          #name: "field_post_text"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\text\Plugin\Field\FieldType\TextLongItem {#2615 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "field_post_trans_credit" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2617
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2032}
          #name: "field_post_trans_credit"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\StringItem {#2623 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "field_post_type" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &76 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2624
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2033}
          #name: "field_post_type"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:2 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2635 …9}
            1 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2637 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &76 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2624}
      ]
      "field_subtitle" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2639
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2035}
          #name: "field_subtitle"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\text\Plugin\Field\FieldType\TextLongItem {#2652 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "field_tags" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &77 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2654
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2036}
          #name: "field_tags"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:5 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2665 …9}
            1 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2667 …9}
            2 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2669 …9}
            3 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2671 …9}
            4 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2673 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &77 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2654}
      ]
      "field_title_displayed" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2675
          #definition: Drupal\field\Entity\FieldConfig {#2037}
          #name: "field_title_displayed"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\text\Plugin\Field\FieldType\TextLongItem {#2688 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "uid" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#2690
          #definition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1950}
          #name: "uid"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#2700 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "title" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2702
          #definition: Drupal\Core\Field\Entity\BaseFieldOverride {#2014}
          #name: "title"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\StringItem {#2708 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "created" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\FieldItemList {#2709
          #definition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1957}
          #name: "created"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\CreatedItem {#2714 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "changed" => array:1 [
        "en" => Drupal\Core\Field\ChangedFieldItemList {#3498
          #definition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1961}
          #name: "changed"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#2558}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\ChangedItem {#3510 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "en"
        }
      ]
      "type" => array:2 [
        "x-default" => &78 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#1880
          #definition: Drupal\Core\Field\BaseFieldDefinition {#1931}
          #name: "type"
          #parent: Drupal\Core\Entity\Plugin\DataType\EntityAdapter {#1896}
          #_serviceIds: []
          #_entityStorages: []
          #stringTranslation: null
          #typedDataManager: Drupal\Core\TypedData\TypedDataManager {#807}
          #list: array:1 [
            0 => Drupal\Core\Field\Plugin\Field\FieldType\EntityReferenceItem {#5277 …9}
          ]
          #langcode: "fr"
        }
        "en" => &78 Drupal\Core\Field\EntityReferenceFieldItemList {#1880}
      ]
    ]
    #fieldDefinitions: null
    #languages: array:4 [
      "fr" => Drupal\Core\Language\Language {#1825}
      "en" => Drupal\Core\Language\Language {#1823}
      "und" => Drupal\Core\Language\Language {#1824}
      "zxx" => Drupal\Core\Language\Language {#1630}
    ]
    #langcodeKey: "langcode"
    #defaultLangcodeKey: "default_langcode"
    #activeLangcode: "x-default"
    #defaultLangcode: "fr"
    #translations: &63 array:2 [&63]
    #translationInitialize: false
    #newRevision: &64 false
    #isDefaultRevision: &65 "1"
    #entityKeys: &66 array:4 [&66]
    #translatableEntityKeys: &67 array:8 [&67]
    #validated: false
    #validationRequired: false
    #loadedRevisionId: &68 "3393"
    #revisionTranslationAffectedKey: "revision_translation_affected"
    #enforceRevisionTranslationAffected: &69 []
    #isSyncing: &70 false
    +in_preview: null
  }
  "item_translations" => array:2 [
    "fr" => Drupal\node\Entity\Node {#1822}
    "en" => Drupal\node\Entity\Node {#1821}
  ]
  "node_id" => "1764"
  "node_type" => "post"
  "page_has_translation" => true
  "param" => []
  "paramstring" => ""
  "uri_translated" => "https://www.hesge.ch/head/issue/publications/art-profondement-ecologique-marie-anne-lanavere"
  "view_id" => null
]
browse summary of Issue #20

In the contemporary art world, a professional sector based on the globalised market economy where I worked for over twenty years as a production manager, a curator, and later as a – mostly public – institution director, environmental awareness only started guiding my choices late in my career. I usually prioritised the production, circulation and transmission of artistic projects, and the ecological paradigm only very occasionally interfered with creative and curatorial freedom.

  • A
  • A

In the contemporary art world, a professional sector based on the globalised market economy where I worked for over twenty years as a production manager, a curator, and later as a – mostly public – institution director, environmental awareness only started guiding my choices late in my career. I usually prioritised the production, circulation and transmission of artistic projects, and the ecological paradigm only very occasionally interfered with creative and curatorial freedom. In the aughts, institutions and private companies alike had to adapt to CSR[note](Editor’s note). Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is the management of a company’s economic, social and environmental impacts.[/note] and various ISO charters and standards, out of a spirit of competitiveness, to clear their conscience, or simply out of conformism. Rather than risking the collapse of the whole system, cultural institutions quickly understood how to circumvent environmental consciousness, which if adhered to would necessarily have turned these structures on their heads. One such loophole consisted in outsourcing the issue to consulting and environmental coaching agencies. Broadly speaking, the foundations, biennales and institutions which I considered to be the most advanced and in step with current social issues had in fact succeeded – by sleight of hand – in addressing environmental matters as though they were external study subjects rather than an internal mechanism they could examine. Although based on worthy intentions, the organisation of research seminars, residencies and exhibitions not with but on the subject of ecology means these institutions can still avoid embracing a truly ecological approach of art. Perversely, without even realising it, they participate in a system that does not acknowledge the urgent necessity of change, bringing the Earth’s overshoot day earlier every year.

Shortcuts enabling action do exist, but these hopes demand that we renounce some of our advantages. An ecological approach necessarily implies that we abandon part of what has been elaborated over the past years; that we relinquish everything that we have capitalised on, in fact: valued social positions, networks, privileges and so on. This is a terribly difficult process to initiate within our professional field, where so much energy is invested in supporting creative projects and assuming a trade union-like role in negotiating statutory rights for the still overwhelmingly precarious artists and art institution workers. However, after years spent campaigning in this way, it finally became apparent to me that art – in what is, to me, its most essential features: poietics, presence and encounter – is in continual decline in our liberalist society. Moreover, though it is increasingly looked down on, art has been unable to eschew the capitalist paradigm that only values production, commodification, and media potential.

However, hope does sporadically blossom in art spaces, through deeply ecological work methods, uniquely embodied by people who resist their financers, their hierarchy and even their colleagues, and who know how to say “no” to artists themselves, however talented, when their creative liberty starts rhyming with economic liberalism.

Integrating artistic labour into a deeply ecological approach that isn’t limited to the use of certified products – such as “PEFC” paper[note](Editor’s note). The Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC) is an international forest certification organisation whose aim is to guarantee the sustainable management of forests, through a certification label for forest owners, timber contractors and companies in the forest, wood, and paper sectors.[/note] for example – implies acknowledging the loss of meaning induced by artistic production itself, particularly with regard to the resources it uses. Where do the materials I work with come from? How do I process them? What will become of them once they are processed? Making responsible choices has become almost impossible in metropolises – centres for trade and commerce where commodities transit from everywhere and nowhere, just as long as you pay. Although cities are deterrestrialised and city life increasingly feels like survival, this is also where hubs of activity, including cultural activity, are still being developed, and where most professional artists live, whether because of spiralling precarity or a lack of alternatives. Over a century ago, William Morris stated that our understanding of materials had been lost, not so much because of industrialisation itself as because of the division of labour necessary to increase productivity: “Even if a tree is cut down or blown down, a worse one, if any, is planted in its stead. […] the very food on which both the greater and the lesser art subsists is being destroyed; the well of art is poisoned at its spring.”[note]William Morris, “Art Under Plutocracy”, Conference at the Russell Club at University College Hall, Oxford, 1883. Reprinted in May Morris (ed.),Collected Works of William Morris (1910-1915), Volume 23, London: Longmans, Green & Co, 1910-15. Available athttps://www.marxists.org/archive/morris/works/1883/pluto.htm (last accessed 3 November 2023).[/note]

Writing from a political territory dealing with the crisis of the sensuous, the contemporary American anthropologist David Abram can help us reframe our relationship to materials not as exploitable resources but as presence:

“Of course, our human-made artifacts inevitably retain an element of more-than-human otherness. This unknowability, this otherness, resides most often in the materials from which the object is made. […] Genuine art, we might say, is simply human creation that does not stifle the nonhuman element but, rather, allows whatever is Other in the materials to continue to live and breathe.”[note]David Abram, The Spell of the Sensuous. Perception and Language in a More-Than-Human World, New York: Vintage Books, 1996, p. 64.[/note]

Because the production and promotion of contemporary art, in this context, are alienating (rather than supporting an encounter with art as otherness), finding a way to connect with materials as presence would not only allow us to better inhabit the Earth but to be inhabited by it in return.

In addition to fostering awareness on the use of materials, deep ecology could also influence the ways in which teams working in cultural institutions collaborate with the artists invited for exhibitions and residencies. Some professional contemporary artists (who suffer from exploitation themselves) unwittingly act in an extractivist manner. In this respect, I have often felt uncomfortable when artists draw inspiration from artisanal knowledge, such as the herbalist’s medicinal plants and Western indigenous wisdom (water diviners, druids, and contemporary healers), when they “steal” this knowledge without giving anything in return, when they syphon inspiration and techniques, or simply when they act too hastily, approaching the understanding of a given territory in a consumerist way. These mechanisms are painful to articulate, especially when one wants to support and respect artists and their work. But I have shared these concerns over the course of the nine years I spent at the head of the Centre International d’Art et du Paysage (CIAP) on Vassivière Island, first and foremost with my team. Together, we discussed our limits and paradoxes. These reflections were developed over time, through cooperation with artists open to debating, particularly Tiphaine Calmettes, Etienne de France, François Génot, Suzanne Husky, L’amicale mille feux, RADO, Liliana Rojas Sanchez, Natsuko Uchino, as well as researchers Cristina Consuegra and Alexis Zimmer, L’école de la terre and my fellow art centre directors Béatrice Josse and Émilie Renard.

In order to guide visiting artists to a subtler understanding of the area, the team members at Vassivière first had to learn how to inhabit their own region. Transmitting a local way of life in order to change the working habits of artists is key in striving towards an ecology of art, not only by drawing inspiration from the histories and cultures of local communities but also by respecting them, to the degree that it is sometimes preferable to keep indigenous and vernacular lore secret, if accessing it implies a long process that requires an extended residency, or that artists come back several times in order to carry out their research.

To live and work ecologically in a specific place means reaffirming a local level that for a long time has been neglected by contemporary art, while also overcoming a very common neo-colonial attitude in our professional practices, by deconstructing the complex power mechanisms that involve the large institutions and small associations that exist in every region.

More specifically, in a rural area like Vassivière, an ecological approach demands that we be more attuned to the territory’s subtle realities, so as not to dominate traditional or less visible forms of knowledge, and to avoid imposing the prism of urban, globalised, contemporary art. One way of working ecologically for me has been to try to slow new CIAP commissions for artworks in public space, after 30 years of accumulating sculptures in the museum’s garden. Even before I applied for the position of director, these permanent outdoor artworks felt like a form of pollution serving the tourist attractiveness of an ungrounded island, whose future was never decided through local cooperation. From 2014 on, my extensive conversations on the subject with Benoît Antille of the Valais School of Art (École de Design et Haute École d’Art du Valais, ÉDHÉA), based on his critique of the project economy in sculpture parks and commissioned art in nature, have helped me to question the functioning of artistic institutions in rural areas.[note]Benoît Antille is currently conducting a doctoral research at the University of Amsterdam, The Artist as Expert: A Critical Analysis of the Project Economy.[/note] We expanded these conversations together during a 2017 symposium at the CIAP, L’art dans l’espace rural (Art in Rural Spaces), and by attending a 2019 seminar at the Whitechapel Gallery (London) entitled The Rural Assembly[note]The Rural Assembly: Contemporary Art and Spaces of Connection [seminar], London: Whitechapel Gallery, 20-22 June 2019.[/note], which helped me solve some of my intellectual predicaments in relation to the right stance to adopt when dealing with these issues.

Considering all the paradoxes and repositioning attempts I have experienced over the past few years, while working in a geographical context defined by the exploitation of resources (such as hydroelectric reservoirs and industrial forests on the Plateau de Millevaches) and public policies for the classification/protection/reservation of “nature”, I have come to realise that it is not necessarily in the places where we believe it is possible to act ecologically that we fully can. In an art centre like Vassivière, when preparing an exhibition for example, it seemed more sustainable to spend time exchanging with the local community, to listen to its aspirations for the space, to communise means in order to implement a form of wealth redistribution, and to allow artists and the team to conduct in-depth research – even if this meant organising fewer exhibitions every year, or travelling less, or occasionally deciding not to be irreproachable when it came to the biodegradability of the materials we used.

Ultimately, addressing contemporary environmental emergencies through/from art signifies relearning how to live by mastering the new skillset of the business of living (and of dying). Adopting a holistic approach shows us that places, nature, ourselves and others are all connected. This requires listening, increasing attentiveness and collaboration, and especially developing our sensorial perception of a more-than-human world, to quote David Abrams, in contrast with what is theoretically prevalent today. To take care of the earth and its lifeforms in everything we do, even when we’re in the city, pertains to a cosmogonic relationship that has largely been lost in Western cultures, and that we can now reinvest, including by drawing inspiration from faraway indigenous and native cultures. The Rencontres de la Ferme de Lachaud (on the Plateau de Millevaches), which I take part in every year since I moved to the Limousin area, have helped me discover and draw inspiration from anthropologists and philosophers of nature, although until recently I was unable to transpose these ideas to my life in any concrete way. The translation into French of the founding texts of ecofeminism, most notably by Cambourakis press, have helped me reconnect with Western forms of paganism, and to discover living ritual and plastic forms in the here and now, rather than having to search for them elsewhere. I organised numerous conferences at the CIAP de Vassivière and elsewhere in this spirit.[note]See for instance the seminar “Habité·e / Être habité·e : quelles relations au vivant ?” organised in Eymoutiers and Cieux (Limousin) in May 2019 by Nicole Pigner, l’École de la terre, and the Cercle Gramsci of Limoges. Also see Barbara Glowczewski and Geneviève Pruvost’s visit of the CIAP with their students of the École des hautes études en sciences sociales (EHESS) to meet local healers, which resulted in the collective publication Des énergies qui soignent en Montagne limousine : Enquête collective (Geneviève Pruvost and Barbara Glowczewski, Lamazière-Basse: Maïade éditions, 2021).[/note]

The change in paradigm that the Western world so urgently needs in order to escape its current crisis demands that, in addition to political struggle, individuals be able to transform themselves in every sense: in their relationship to the senses, to others, to sexuality, to love, to nature, and so on. Taking this risk may entail a painful endangerment, which can only be achieved by renouncing certain privileges, in order to better nurture the attachments we really care about.

“So, it is no longer a matter of a system of production picking up again or being curbed, but one of getting away from production as the overriding principle of our relationship to the world. …. Hence the primary importance for using this time of imposed isolation in order to describe, initially one by one, then as a group, what we are attached to; what we are ready to give up; the chains we are ready to reconstruct and those that, in our behaviour, we have decided to interrupt.”[note]Bruno Latour, “What protective measures can you think of so we don’t go back to the pre-crisis production model?” http://www.bruno-latour.fr/sites/default/files/downloads/P-202-AOC-ENGLISH_0.pdf; “Imaginer les gestes-barrières contre le retour à la production d’avant-crise”, AOC, 29 March 2020, http://www.bruno-latour.fr/fr/node/849 (last accessed 8 February 2023).[/note]

This was philosopher Bruno Latour’s advice during the first Covid-19 lockdown in France, which he expounded in an article and later in participative workshops entitled Où Atterrir (Where should we land?) created with S-composition[note]S-composition is a theatre company founded in 2004 by composer and producer Jean-Pierre Seyvos: https://s-composition.eu/ (last accessed 10 March 2023).[/note] at La Mégisserie in Saint-Junien, near Limoges and elsewhere.

Although this appeal, which acted as a wake-up call in cultural milieus, has undeniably helped me to implement change on a personal level, I also needed it to take the form of narratives that spoke directly to my emotions. Nastassja Martin’s deeply moving story, published in 2019, seems like a perfect example, because of the revolutionary adequacy between her poetic style of writing, her object of study – the Evene people of Siberia – and her own transformation, not only as a researcher but as an individual in her relationship to reality.[note]Nastassja Martin, In the Eye of the Wild [2019], translated by Sophie R. Lewis, New York: New York Review Books, 2021.[/note] Closer to home, artist Boris Nordmann, in collaboration with the association Quartier Rouge based in Felletin (Creuse department), has been organising workshops since 2017, during which work around the human body echoes the observation of animal behaviour and writing experiments, where subjective experience meets anthropological considerations. In his “corporeal fiction”, Lou Pastoral, Nordmann puts himself at risk when connecting with his research subject, an endangerment that is similar to Nastassja Martin’s stance. He simultaneously succeeds in embodying corporeal forms and showing the necessity of reversing our point of view.

When Latour’s aforementioned text, “What protective measures can you think of so we don’t go back to the pre-crisis production model?” was published, I was still in office at the CIAP de Vassivières, and rather than cultivating my interest in art’s ability to change the world, I had started realising that in order to actually change things, I needed to start by changing my own life, scale down my material needs, and be more mindful of the needs of my close relations and other more-than-human beings. Before Covid happened, my team had already asked that we put on fewer exhibitions, but it wasn’t before I was engulfed in multiple crises that I started understanding how I should act. At the same time as I was experiencing a crisis of responsibility as the director of an institution, my child was having behavioural problems in school, which led me to another crisis, a parenting one. I finally left the CIAP in April 2021, in order to devote myself entirely to leading a better life and to loving differently.

I have now joined a collective organisation – which is still embryonic and imperfect, due to the fact that it is constantly evolving – because I believe it is the best thing I can do in the face of the environmental crisis on my own level, that is, based on my current experience and means. Here, my comrades offer me sensitive and intellectual support which helps me see through the scam of green transition. By contrast, I recognise the potential of small-scale action by working from a broader criticism of the capitalist production model. For me, this is one of the conditions for operating a paradigm shift and moving away from the model that Western patriarchal modernity has imposed on us for centuries. In concrete terms, this demands that I move out of my comfort zone in order to transform myself, by learning about autonomy and communisation, two vital aspects which I had neglected until then. Now, with others, I am imagining a form of food-producing agriculture that will be able, on the long term, to feed dozens in the area, as well as a way of cultivating and farming that fosters sharing with more-than-humans. On a broader scale, I am trying to contribute to a project that to me seems like it could become an inspiring model for exchanging with other groups, through the networked transmission of forms of knowledge and experimentations, not at the margins of society but in permanent connection with beings, the earth and the world.

Artistically, I feel a greater freedom than in my previous occupation, even though, during those twenty years, I did try to find my way into the interstices that the profession offered: attempting to express, from the margins of the exhibition, ideas from outside the frame, from places of latency and emergence, embracing the partly hidden meanings that could appear in these spatial and temporal intervals, and manifesting the unexpected connections between different artworks. These approaches were so invisible that only a few friends from the contemporary art world followed me down this path – Gyan Panchal, Caroline Ferreira, Anne Bonnin, Simone Menegoi, Marjorie Micucci and Cécilia Becanovic. I am grateful to them for sharing their emotions with me; without them I would have collapsed a lot sooner!

Now, I let myself try things out without worrying beforehand whether they are art or not. These days, whatever I create, I create with pleasure, particularly because I am producing things for my friends: a poster to advertise the spring cleaning of our community centre, an invitation to the collective potato harvest, etc. And when I am asked to contribute to a contemporary art catalogue, now I am brave enough to send in a drawing, embracing its illustrative function and its non-referenced style.

Isn’t ecological art amateur by definition? Devoid of any professional aim, ecological art should be integrated into our everyday existences, and should reach out to all areas of life.

It should be useful in the same way applied arts are, but also in the sense that all art forms – even when they are created for no particular purpose – seem to be universally useful, if only because they transform our perception of the world.

Another characteristic of this deeply ecological art I so much want to see materialise is that it is an art of the common, in other words, an art created in the service of a common cause, for a group or a village. Yet at present, most artists create objects individually, which, in the best-case scenario, will then be shown publicly. Although cultural policies increasingly incentivise displaying artworks to “audiences” in order to justify public spending on the arts (which represents barely 1% of France’s global budget), I have often noticed that making an artwork public, exhibiting it, organising Q&A sessions with the artist, and so on, does not necessarily go hand in hand with the communisation of art, despite the best efforts of the professionals involved. The examples of art of the commons that I have taken part in recently are very different in this respect, because they are planned by the artists in co-creation with amateur groups: a parade for the Day of the Dead performed by a group of ten locals and initiated by Cellule d’Actions Rituelles in 2019, an installation of food cooked in ovens built for the occasion in a public building by Doriane Albert and Anna Gianferrari (of the FEU association) in 2021, an altar for the dead created collectively and accessible 24 hours a day…[note]All these performances took place in the village of Faux-la-Montagne (Plateau de Millevaches) during the Samhain festivities organised by the association Par la racine, which guides local communities in their relationship to death.[/note] Artists offer their talent to the community, sometimes anonymously, and they accept that the end result no longer belongs to them. Note how these forms of art of the common are ecological in the sense that they are precisely located in space and time. They happen locally, becoming important moments in the life of the individuals or groups taking part in their realisation (unlike unknown viewers who discover artworks once they are finished).

Lastly, deeply ecological art should be connected to the earth and to more-than-human beings, not as a theme (i.e. an artwork dealing with agriculture) or as a skill (i.e. the art of agriculture). It should be completely integrated into cultivation practices. From the space I inhabit, when I examine the different agricultural methods at my disposal, biodynamic farming seems to ideally connect the gestures of cultivation with the microbiological and cosmic levels. In a field so drastically affected by the mind/body, subject/object dichotomies, which have become all the more flagrant in the wake of industrial agriculture and its irreversible consequences on all lifeforms, for the past century the biodynamic approach has been trying to recreate a connection between sensory perceptions and nurturing practices. When I started working as a farmer, this connection suddenly started seeming familiar, due to my knowledge of art history – through the historical links between the biodynamic approach and artistic practices ranging from dance to painting – and especially because of my interest in certain processes that are present in art and in agriculture alike, such as losing control, transitory states, incompletion, shapelessness…

Earth-based energetic practices, which are less widespread in the cities where I worked (although they are fashionable there too – to a certain degree at least, since they are considered to be just as irrational as biodynamic farming is in academic and professional environments), open up approaches to some of the earth’s unexplained aspects – at least through the practices I can access in France right now: intuitive communication, geobiology, garden harmonisation, and so on. In these practices, sensorial experience is central. Unlike agricultural policies which focus only on hyperproduction, through the prism of energetic practices I can consider food-producing agriculture that is not only aimed at feeding me, a human, but at creating a balance between other visible and invisible beings. Wasn’t this exactly the dimension that interested me in contemporary art to begin with?

Artists such as Suzanne Husky and Etienne de France have helped me envision a space for exchanges between art and farming: Suzanne through ecofeminism, Etienne through speculative fiction.

I now try to connect earth-based practices and art practices by drawing from energetic methods, considered as a bridge between two worlds that used to be separate.

I can achieve this by cherry-picking techniques during courses, workshops and trainings, but my theoretical base is still shaky. Thanks to a conversation with Nicole Pignier,[note]A semiotician and researcher at the Limoges Faculty of Literature and Science, she has contributed to creating a school for the planetary garden alongside Gilles Clément and the Lycée agricole des Vaseix, in the form of a B.A. in “Aménagement paysager, design des milieux anthropisés” (Design and landscaping of anthropized environments). See her talk at the École nationale supérieure d’art de Limoges (ENSAD) during the seminar Matière et architecture : de la terre au territoire, October 2021, available at https://youtu.be/hfKDJHGCWMs (last accessed 8 February 2023).[/note] I have been able to connect cultural and cultivation practices in a neatly conceptual way. Based on the works of Augustin Berque, Pignier foregrounds a co-articulation of the living through the gestures of farming. The accounts of the farmers she introduced us to, and that she recorded talking about their relationship to livestock and garden farming gave me a great deal of hope for the future of our world.

Working on a fruit and tree farm armed with my artistic perspective, I consider each plant and tree simultaneously as a singular being and as part of a whole. For the first time, I have encountered the earth, which holds minerals, vegetables, animals, living and dead creatures, some of which will remain foreign to me forever. Earth gives, even when we don’t know how to give back. I have only just begun imagining a form of ecology stemming from art.[note]For further information, see Marie-Anne Lanavère “Marianne Lanavère jette son costume de directrice aux orties (entretien avec Émilie Renard)”, Lili, no. 3, 2021, p. 122-128, https://www.la-criee.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/REVUE_3_WEB_page.pdf (Last visited: 8.2.2023), and Manon Simons, La part invisible, film for Télémillevaches, 2021, 16 min., https://telemillevaches.net/videos/la-part-invisible/ (last accessed 8 February 2023).[/note]

 

notes

  1. (Editor’s note). Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is the management of a company’s economic, social and environmental impacts.
  2. (Editor’s note). The Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC) is an international forest certification organisation whose aim is to guarantee the sustainable management of forests, through a certification label for forest owners, timber contractors and companies in the forest, wood, and paper sectors.
  3. William Morris, “Art Under Plutocracy”, Conference at the Russell Club at University College Hall, Oxford, 1883. Reprinted in May Morris (ed.),Collected Works of William Morris (1910-1915), Volume 23, London: Longmans, Green & Co, 1910-15. Available athttps://www.marxists.org/archive/morris/works/1883/pluto.htm (last accessed 3 November 2023).
  4. David Abram, The Spell of the Sensuous. Perception and Language in a More-Than-Human World, New York: Vintage Books, 1996, p. 64.
  5. Benoît Antille is currently conducting a doctoral research at the University of Amsterdam, The Artist as Expert: A Critical Analysis of the Project Economy.
  6. The Rural Assembly: Contemporary Art and Spaces of Connection [seminar], London: Whitechapel Gallery, 20-22 June 2019.
  7. See for instance the seminar “Habité·e / Être habité·e : quelles relations au vivant ?” organised in Eymoutiers and Cieux (Limousin) in May 2019 by Nicole Pigner, l’École de la terre, and the Cercle Gramsci of Limoges. Also see Barbara Glowczewski and Geneviève Pruvost’s visit of the CIAP with their students of the École des hautes études en sciences sociales (EHESS) to meet local healers, which resulted in the collective publication Des énergies qui soignent en Montagne limousine : Enquête collective (Geneviève Pruvost and Barbara Glowczewski, Lamazière-Basse: Maïade éditions, 2021).
  8. Bruno Latour, “What protective measures can you think of so we don’t go back to the pre-crisis production model?” http://www.bruno-latour.fr/sites/default/files/downloads/P-202-AOC-ENGLISH_0.pdf; “Imaginer les gestes-barrières contre le retour à la production d’avant-crise”, AOC, 29 March 2020, http://www.bruno-latour.fr/fr/node/849 (last accessed 8 February 2023).
  9. S-composition is a theatre company founded in 2004 by composer and producer Jean-Pierre Seyvos: https://s-composition.eu/ (last accessed 10 March 2023).
  10. Nastassja Martin, In the Eye of the Wild [2019], translated by Sophie R. Lewis, New York: New York Review Books, 2021.
  11. All these performances took place in the village of Faux-la-Montagne (Plateau de Millevaches) during the Samhain festivities organised by the association Par la racine, which guides local communities in their relationship to death.
  12. A semiotician and researcher at the Limoges Faculty of Literature and Science, she has contributed to creating a school for the planetary garden alongside Gilles Clément and the Lycée agricole des Vaseix, in the form of a B.A. in “Aménagement paysager, design des milieux anthropisés” (Design and landscaping of anthropized environments). See her talk at the École nationale supérieure d’art de Limoges (ENSAD) during the seminar Matière et architecture : de la terre au territoire, October 2021, available at https://youtu.be/hfKDJHGCWMs (last accessed 8 February 2023).
  13. For further information, see Marie-Anne Lanavère “Marianne Lanavère jette son costume de directrice aux orties (entretien avec Émilie Renard)”, Lili, no. 3, 2021, p. 122-128, https://www.la-criee.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/REVUE_3_WEB_page.pdf (Last visited: 8.2.2023), and Manon Simons, La part invisible, film for Télémillevaches, 2021, 16 min., https://telemillevaches.net/videos/la-part-invisible/ (last accessed 8 February 2023).